Bullish Target Unchanged, Yet State Street Cuts Its Position by 10%

The Bullish Target Remains Untouched
Why State Street Cut Its Probability Estimate by 10 Percentage Points

Seemingly maintaining a bullish stance,
in reality shifting positions toward range-bound consolidation

Key Takeaways ● State Street Investment Management’s October edition of the Gold Monthly Observation maintains its base-case forecast for gold prices at $4,750–$5,500 per ounce by the end of Q1 2027, but lowers the probability of this scenario occurring from 70% to 60%. ● The narrative of “bullishness up to $5,500” requires correction: $5,500 is merely the upper bound of the range; the same report raises the probability of a bearish scenario (gold prices remaining in the $4,000–$4,750 range) from 25% to 35%. ● As of the Asian session on October 28, spot gold was approximately $4,038 per ounce. A rise of roughly 17.6% (calculated) would be needed to return to the lower bound of $4,750, while market pricing implies an over 80% probability of a rate hike in December. ● Prices are falling, yet physical buying persists: Global gold ETF holdings increased by 67 tonnes to a record 4,256 tonnes in September; the People’s Bank of China added approximately 23 tonnes in a single month; meanwhile, COMEX speculative long positions decreased by an equivalent of approximately 84 tonnes. ● Mining Cube Assessment: The probability of gold prices standing above $4,750 by the end of Q1 is less than 50%. Gold prices are more likely to consolidate in the $4,000–$4,600 range. $4,000 represents the “central bank floor,” not the “trend ceiling.”

01 The Catalyst

From 70% to 60%: What State Street Changed

On October 27 (US time), Kitco reported the core conclusions of State Street Investment Management’s latest Gold Monthly Observation. This October edition was authored by the SPDR Gold Strategy team led by Aakash Doshi, Head of Gold Strategy at State Street, with data current as of September 30. The report maintained its previous base case, forecasting gold prices rising to $4,750–$5,500 per ounce by the end of Q1 2027, but lowered the probability of this scenario from 70% to 60%, citing headwinds from Federal Reserve policy and a stronger US dollar.

The headline of the source material stated, “State Street Still Bullish on Gold Up to $5,500 Against the Trend,” which requires correction. $5,500 is the upper bound of the base-case range, not a single target price provided by State Street. Kitco’s article headline used the phrase, “Gold Price Still Has a Path to $5,000”; during an interview in late September, Doshi himself assessed that $4,000 could be the bottom and that gold prices could reach $5,000 before June 2027. Treating the upper bound of the range as a target price makes State Street’s position appear more aggressive than it actually is.

More notably, the source material omitted the other half of the story. The same report assigned a 35% probability to the bearish scenario, defined here as gold prices remaining within the $4,000–$4,750 range—which the market had traversed in Q3—for the next 6 to 9 months. Comparing this to the July edition, where the bearish scenario probability was 25%, the 10 percentage points subtracted from the base case were almost entirely shifted to the “range-bound consolidation” category. This is the true informational content of this adjustment.

ScenarioPrice Range (USD)July EditionOctober Edition
Base Case$4,750–$5,500 (by end of Q1 2027)70%60%
Bear Case$4,000–$4,750 (next 6–9 months)25%35%
Bull Case$5,500–$6,2505%~5%

This is not a rehash of old news. In the July edition, the base case probability was 70%, the bear case was 25%, and the bull case was 5%; the 60% and 35% figures in the October edition represent new adjustments made in this issue. The timing of the report’s release is also subtle: The Federal Reserve’s interest rate decision for October was announced at 2:00 PM ET on October 28 (2:00 AM Beijing Time on October 29). Markets widely expected rates to remain unchanged, but a December rate hike was largely priced in as a certainty. State Street precisely adjusted its expectations down one notch during this window.

02 Background

Falling from $5,589 Back to the $4,000 Threshold

To understand why State Street “lowered probabilities without lowering targets,” we must first lay out the path gold prices have taken through 2026. In late January, gold prices hit all-time highs, with peak values recorded between $5,589 and $5,595 depending on the data source. Immediately following this, on January 30, spot gold plummeted approximately 9.5% in a single day, marking the largest single-day decline since 1983. Subsequently, gold prices oscillated downward, accumulating losses of approximately 14% in Q2, making it the worst-performing quarter since 2013. On June 25, the London Bullion Market Association (LBMA) price briefly fell to $3,994.50.

The primary driver of the decline was interest rates. In mid-June, the first interest rate meeting chaired by newly appointed Fed Chair Kevin Warsh sent a distinctly hawkish signal. On September 16, the Fed raised rates by 25 basis points, raising the target range for the federal funds rate to 3.75%–4.00%, the first hike since July 2023. Although gold prices rebounded above $4,400 in August leveraging weaker US employment data, they retreated again after the September rate hike. Regarding the monthly decline in September, State Street’s figure was 6.3%, while the World Gold Council’s figure was 8.5%. While their methodologies differ, the direction is consistent; the World Gold Council reported a closing price of $4,176 at the end of September.

TimeEventGold Price (USD)
Late JanuaryRecord highs on Jan 28–29Approx. $5,589–$5,595 (varies by source)
Jan 30Single-day drop of approx. 9.5%, largest since 1983Approx. $4,884
Q2Quarterly drop of approx. 14%, worst quarter since 2013LBMA price of $3,994.50 on June 25
Sep 16Fed raises rates by 25 bps to 3.75%–4.00%Approx. $4,350 in mid-September
End of SeptemberSeptember drop of 6.3% (State Street) / 8.5% (WGC)$4,176
Oct 23Closing price broke below $4,000$3,995.63
Oct 28Fed interest rate decision day, Asian sessionApprox. $4,038

Entering October, gold prices probed the $4,000 level once again. According to summaries from Sina Finance, international spot gold closed at $3,995.63 last Friday (October 23), hitting a three-month low. During the Asian session on October 28, spot gold quoted $4,037.98. Domestically, the main contract for Shanghai Gold futures quoted 870.58 RMB/gram during the daytime session on October 28; Shanghai Gold Exchange Gold T+D closed at 860.45 RMB/gram on October 27. For comparison, the central bank-published closing price for Au(T+D) at the end of February was still 1,142.5 RMB/gram, meaning domestic gold prices have fallen by more than 400 RMB per gram from their yearly high.

After prices fell back into the “800s” range (referring to the RMB price per gram), a clear wave of bargain-hunting emerged in the domestic retail sector, with queues forming at gold shops in multiple locations and gold bars temporarily selling out. This phenomenon itself indicates one thing: near the $4,000 level, there is no shortage of buyers. What is lacking is incremental capital capable of pushing prices back above $4,750, which is precisely the concern State Street highlighted when lowering its probability estimate.

03 Breakdown

Where Did Those Ten Percentage Points Go?

State Street’s three scenarios can be interpreted in another way: by multiplying the midpoint of each scenario’s range by its probability, one obtains a probability-weighted expected price. Using the weights from the July report, the expected value is approximately $4,975; using the October report’s weights and assuming the bull case remains at 5%, the expected value is approximately $4,900—a decline of only about $75, or roughly 1.5% (calculated). In other words, State Street’s judgment on where gold prices will “ultimately end up” has hardly changed; what has changed is their confidence in “when they will get there.”

ScenarioMidpointJuly WeightOctober Weight
Base Case512570%60%
Bear Case437525%35%
Bull Case58755%5%
Weighted Expected Value—~4975~4900

The real difficulty lies in timing. Starting from approximately $4,038 on October 28, there are roughly five months remaining until the end of March 2027. According to calculations by MineCube, returning to the lower bound of the base case at $4,750 requires an increase of 17.6%, which equates to an average monthly rise of 3.3% over five consecutive months; reaching the base case midpoint of $5,125 requires an increase of 26.9%; and reaching the upper bound of $5,500 requires an increase of 36.2%. Against the backdrop of the Federal Reserve still being in a rate-hiking cycle, achieving an average monthly gain of over 3% for five consecutive months is not easy.

Target Price (USD)Gain from Current PriceRequired Average Monthly Gain
4750 (Base Lower Bound)17.6%3.3%
5125 (Base Midpoint)26.9%4.9%
5500 (Base Upper Bound)36.2%6.4%
4375 (Bear Midpoint)8.3%1.6%

Current price taken as Asian session spot gold at $4,038 on October 28; data in the table are MineCube calculations, with average monthly gains converted based on compound interest.

Another detail easily overlooked is that State Street’s description of the bear case is “maintaining the realized price range from Q3.” In other words, the bear case does not mean “continued sharp declines,” but rather “staying put.” Raising the probability of this scenario from 25% to 35% means State Street acknowledges that, over the next six months, gold prices ranging sideways between $4,000 and $4,750 is the second most likely outcome after a rebound. This does not entirely align with the impression given by the headline “Bullish Despite Headwinds.”

04 Breakdown

Interest Rates and the US Dollar Pressuring Gold Prices

State Street identified only two headwinds: the Federal Reserve and the US dollar. Looking closely, neither of these forces shows signs of easing. According to State Street’s October report, as of August 25, the market anticipated cumulative rate hikes of approximately 1.5 times between September 2026 and June 2027; following the September FOMC meeting, the market shifted to pricing in approximately 3.3 additional rate hikes over the next nine months, expecting the federal funds rate to rise to 4.75%–5% by next summer. CME FedWatch data showed that as of October 28, the market assigned an approximately 84% probability to a December rate hike.

IndicatorLatest ReadingSource
Federal Funds Rate Range3.75%–4.00%Federal Reserve
Probability of Holding Rates Steady in October>90%CME
Probability of Rate Hike in December~84%CME
Pricing for Rate Hikes Over Next 9 Months~3.3 timesState Street
US September CPI YoY3.7%Compiled by EBC, etc.
US September Non-Farm Payrolls29,000Compiled by EBC, etc.
10-Year US Treasury Yield~5.14%Mitrade
US Dollar Index~102.5TMGM
2026 Core PCE Forecast3.4%Federal Reserve

Note: CME refers to the CME FedWatch tool; the rate range reflects the result of the September 16 decision; CME data represents readings around October 28; the 10-year Treasury yield is from late October; the core PCE forecast comes from the Federal Reserve’s September economic projections, which expect it to return to 2% only by 2029.

Inflation and employment are at odds: September CPI was 3.7% year-on-year, while non-farm payroll additions were only 29,000. This combination led the Federal Reserve to hold steady in October, yet remain unwilling to rule out a December rate hike. According to a mid-October Reuters survey, 94 out of 100 economists predicted no change in October, while all 100 predicted a rate hike in December. For non-yielding gold, “rate hikes are not yet over” itself constitutes the greatest pressure; as US Treasury yields and the dollar strengthen simultaneously, the opportunity cost of holding gold continues to rise.

Technically, State Street listed several key levels in its report. At the end of September, gold prices broke below the 50-day moving average of approximately $4,322 and the 200-day moving average of approximately $4,539; both moving averages will act as resistance during any rebound. The 61.8% Fibonacci retracement level at approximately $4,231 has been lost; reclaiming it would signal easing selling pressure. The Fibonacci support at approximately $4,121 held at the end of Q3; further downside leads to the psychological barrier of $4,000.

LevelNatureImplication
~4539200-Day Moving AverageSecond resistance level for rebounds
~432250-Day Moving AverageFirst resistance level for rebounds
~423161.8% Fibonacci RetracementBroken; reclaiming implies easing selling pressure
~4121Fibonacci SupportHeld at end of Q3
~4000Key BottomPsychological barrier jointly monitored by State Street and multiple institutions

State Street also outlined a potential path to reverse the situation: if the Federal Reserve overestimates productivity gains driven by artificial intelligence, the next policy error may not be “underestimating inflation,” but rather “excessive tightening.” In such a scenario, economic growth slows while inflation remains high; a stagflationary environment is precisely when gold can best serve as a hedge. However, this path requires time for verification and is unlikely to complete the transmission from expectations to prices within five months.

05 Comparison

Futures Sold, Physical Bought

If looking only at prices, September was a poor month for gold; but if looking at physical demand, September was actually a good month. Data from the World Gold Council show that global gold ETFs saw net inflows of $10 billion in September, with holdings increasing by 67 tons to reach a historical record of 4,256 tons; total inflows for the third quarter amounted to $31 billion, also a record. According to MineCube calculations, global gold ETF holdings now equal approximately 1.1 times the global mine gold production for 2025.

ItemSeptember / Latest DataSource
Global Gold ETFs$10 billion inflow in September; holdings increased by 67 tonnes to a record 4,256 tonnes; Q3 inflows totaled $31 billion, setting a recordWorld Gold Council
US-Listed Gold ETFsQ3 inflows of $11.7 billion, including $3.7 billion in September; Q2 saw outflows of $5.6 billionState Street
COMEX Managed MoneyNet long positions decreased by approximately 84 tonnes equivalent in SeptemberWorld Gold Council / BMO
People’s Bank of China (PBOC)Increased holdings by 740,000 ounces (approx. 23 tonnes) in September, marking the 23rd consecutive month of increases; reserves stand at approx. 2,410 tonnesState Administration of Foreign Exchange (SAFE) / World Gold Council
Global Central BanksReported net gold purchases of 170 tonnes from January to August; preliminary estimates for September are approx. 63 tonnesWorld Gold Council / Financial Times
China Gold ImportsConsumption-driven gold imports reached 1,141 tonnes from January to August, setting a same-period recordState Street October Edition

Note: The conversion of 740,000 ounces to approximately 23.0 tonnes is calculated by Kuanglifang. Kitco reported that the PBOC increased its holdings by 21 tonnes in September, which differs from the result derived using SAFE data. This report prioritizes the ounce figures provided by SAFE.

Why did prices still fall? The World Gold Council and BMO attribute this to futures selling: in September, net long positions among COMEX managed money funds decreased by approximately 84 tonnes equivalent, while spread positions also reduced by about 156 tonnes. In other words, short-term price movements are driven by interest-rate-sensitive futures capital, while ETFs and central banks are buying dips. The PBOC increased its holdings by 740,000 ounces in September, the largest single-month increase since 2023. The proportion of gold in China’s official reserves has risen to 8.5%, up from 5.5% at the end of 2024.

There is also indirect evidence from the supply side. Data cited by State Street indicates that global mine gold production will be approximately 3,823 tonnes in 2025; the ratio of recycled gold to mine gold production has declined from 57% during 2010–2012 to 37% in the first half of 2025. With gold prices at historical highs, sellers’ willingness to offload holdings has actually decreased, indicating that physical market positions are quite stable.

Looking at how peers view the market, comparing forecasts from several major institutions reveals that State Street is neither isolated nor particularly conservative. UBS expects gold prices to reach $4,600 by December this year, $5,000 by March 2027, and $5,200 by June 2027. On June 18, Goldman Sachs lowered its year-end 2026 target from $5,400 to $4,900; additionally, according to summaries compiled by various financial websites, Goldman Sachs further reduced it to $4,650 in September, while maintaining its year-end 2027 target of $5,400.

InstitutionEnd of 20262027Date
State Street—Q1 2027: $4,750–$5,500 (60% probability)October
UBSDecember: $4,600March: $5,000; June: $5,200August
Goldman Sachs$4,900 (down from $5,400 in June); reports suggest reduction to $4,650 in SeptemberYear-end 2027: $5,400June, September
JPMorganQ4 average price: $4,500 (down in July)Varies by reportJuly

Note: UBS data is based on reports from multiple media outlets in August; JPMorgan’s downward adjustment in July was reported by Reuters. Goldman Sachs’ September reduction to $4,650 and its year-end 2027 target of $5,400, as well as JPMorgan’s 2027 target, are sourced from summaries on financial websites and have not yet been independently verified against original reports.

At the same point in time, UBS’s March 2027 target of $5,000 falls within State Street’s base range but near the lower half. The consensus among mainstream institutions is actually that gold will return to around $5,000 in the first quarter of next year, rather than $5,500. This indirectly suggests that treating $5,500 as a bullish target in the source material may lead to misinterpretation.

06 Assessment

In a rate-hiking cycle, the floor is clearer than the ceiling.

Kuanglifang’s assessment is that State Street’s 60% base-case probability remains somewhat optimistic; the probability of gold prices standing above $4,750 by the end of Q1 2027 is less than 50%. A more likely scenario involves repeated bottoming out in the $4,000–$4,600 range: there is support near $4,000 from central banks and Chinese physical demand, but before the Federal Reserve’s rate-hiking cycle clearly peaks, it is difficult to see a market movement returning above $4,750.

There are three reasons for this. First is timing. A 17.6% rise over five months requires an average monthly increase of 3.3%; however, market pricing shows an approximately 80% probability of a rate hike in December, with policy rates potentially rising to 4.75%–5% by next summer. Without a shift in interest rate expectations, the opportunity cost of holding gold will not decrease, and rebounds are likely to face resistance around the 50-day and 200-day moving averages.

Second is State Street’s own wording. The bear case is defined as “maintaining the realized range from Q3,” and this probability has already risen to 35%. When a bullish institution increases the weight of “doing nothing” by ten percentage points, this itself represents a downgrade of short-term upward momentum and should not be interpreted as “adding to bullish bets against the trend.”

Third is the nature of physical buying. Record ETF holdings, 23 consecutive months of central bank accumulation, and 1,141 tonnes of Chinese imports failed to prevent the September decline. These buying forces act more like a “floor” rather than a “rocket”: they determine how deep prices can fall, but not how fast they can rise. Therefore, repeated testing without breaking below $4,000 is more consistent with the current balance of forces than a rapid rebound above $4,750.

Of course, this judgment carries clear upside risks. If the third-quarter GDP and September PCE data released on October 29 are weak, or if the Fed signals at its October meeting that a December hike is not certain, a retreat in rate-hike expectations could allow gold prices to quickly reclaim $4,231 and challenge the 50-day moving average at $4,322. For gold mining companies and traders, even if gold prices remain at $4,000, they are still at historical highs, leaving considerable profit margins; short-term price fluctuations primarily affect inventory pacing rather than operational fundamentals.

07 Outlook

Three signals determine the upper bound of the range.

Tracking Point 1: The Federal Reserve’s Monetary Policy Meeting on December 9 and Monthly PCE Data. The outcome of the October meeting will be announced at dawn on October 29 Beijing Time, followed by initial third-quarter GDP figures and September PCE data in the evening. If the probability of a December rate hike drops below 50% from the current level of over 80%, it implies that headwinds from interest rates are beginning to loosen, significantly increasing the likelihood of gold prices reclaiming $4,231 and challenging $4,322. Conversely, if rate-hike expectations continue to heat up, the $4,000 threshold will come under pressure again.

Tracking Point 2: China’s October Reserve Data to be Released by the PBOC in Early November. In September, the PBOC increased holdings by approximately 23 tonnes despite falling gold prices, marking the largest single-month increase in nearly three years. If the PBOC maintains an increase of over 20 tonnes in October amidst gold prices falling below $4,000, and if the World Gold Council’s statistics show global central bank gold purchases remaining above 50 tonnes per month, the characterization of $4,000 as the “central bank floor” will receive further confirmation.

Tracking Point 3: $4,000 per ounce for spot gold, approximately RMB 860 per gram for Shanghai Gold (Au99.99), and global ETF holdings. Spot gold at $4,000 corresponds to the domestic Shanghai Gold price of around RMB 860 per gram. Key focus should be placed on whether global gold ETF holdings begin to decline from their record high of 4,256 metric tons if the gold price breaks below $4,000. If both ETF holdings and central bank gold purchases weaken simultaneously, the support floor may shift lower, with the next reference level being near $3,850, as previously indicated by UBS; however, if ETFs continue to increase positions against the trend, a range-bound trading pattern will essentially be established.

Interest rates cap the ceiling, while central banks elevate the floor.

— END —