Gold Price Falls Below $3,900 to Hit Yearly Low

Safe-Haven Appeal Seems to Fail as Fed Resumes Rate Hikes

Key Takeaways ● On November 12, spot gold prices fell nearly 2.8% in a single day, hitting an intraday low of $3,852 per ounce; on the 13th, during the Asian session, prices rebounded, reclaiming the $3,900 level and ending a three-day losing streak. ● The direct driver is inflation: October CPI rose 0.4% month-over-month, higher than the expected 0.3%, while core CPI rose by 0.3% for the third consecutive month; CME data shows the market assigns an approximately 85% probability to a 25-basis-point rate hike in December and a 15% probability to a 50-basis-point hike. ● The Federal Reserve already raised rates by 25 basis points to 3.75%–4.00% on September 16 with a unanimous 12-0 vote, marking the first rate hike since July 2023 and signaling the start of this tightening cycle; the meeting on December 8–9 could be the second hike. ● Physical demand has not collapsed: World Gold Council data shows that global central banks net purchased 321 tons of gold in the third quarter, a year-on-year increase of 42%, the highest since Q4 2024; however, bullion and coin demand fell 19% year-on-year, dropping to a four-year low. ● MineCube Assessment: The primary cause of the gold price decline is rising holding costs, not a failure of its safe-haven appeal; as long as rate hike expectations have not peaked, gold prices will struggle to escape pressure, and a true bottom will only emerge when there are signals that interest rates have topped out.

01 The Trigger

A Single CPI Report Crushes Gold Prices

On November 12, spot gold prices fell nearly 2.8% in a single day, touching an intraday low of $3,852 per ounce, setting a new yearly low. This marked the second time gold prices had broken below $3,900, following the drop on October 30. At that time, gold prices fell to approximately $3,870 intraday, with the entire month of October seeing a decline of 6.87%.

The trigger was inflation data released two days prior. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported on November 10 that the October CPI rose 0.4% month-over-month, higher than the market expectation of 0.3%; core CPI rose 0.3% month-over-month, also exceeding the expected 0.2%, and this marked the third consecutive month of 0.3% increases. Due to the government shutdown in October 2025, no price data was collected for that month, so the year-on-year figure was not published in this report; the year-on-year increase for September was 3.7%.

Breakdowns further unsettled the market. Gasoline prices rose 1.0% that month, serving as the main driver for the overall CPI increase; core goods prices excluding used cars rose 0.4%, the largest increase since January; "supercore" inflation, defined as core services excluding housing, rose 0.4%, translating to an annualized rate of nearly 5.5% over the past three months. Meanwhile, October saw 165,000 new jobs added, far exceeding the monthly average of 48,000 over the previous year; average hourly earnings rose 3.1% year-on-year, lagging behind price increases for seven consecutive months. Strong employment combined with sticky inflation leaves the Federal Reserve with little reason to stop hiking rates. The issue of prices was also one of the most closely watched topics among voters in the recently concluded U.S. midterm elections, transforming inflation from an economic issue into a political one.

Federal Reserve Governor Waller subsequently stated that if core inflation remains high, a 50-basis-point hike should be considered in December. CME FedWatch data shows the market assigns an approximately 85% probability to a 25-basis-point rate hike in December and a 15% probability to a 50-basis-point hike; just a week ago, the market believed the likelihood of a 50-basis-point hike was virtually zero. Cleveland Fed President Lorie Hamack also publicly stated that the Federal Reserve has failed to meet its inflation target for many years. Following the CPI release, The Wall Street Journal cited CME data stating that the probabilities for 25-basis-point and 50-basis-point hikes were approximately 90% and 10%, respectively; on the prediction market Polymarket, the combined probability of these two rate hike contracts was approximately 97.7%. During the Asian session on the 13th, gold prices rebounded slightly above $3,900, ending the three-day losing streak.

IndicatorOctober ReadingExpectationPrevious Value
CPI MoM0.4%0.3%0.6%
Core CPI MoM0.3%0.2%0.3%
Supercore (Services ex-Housing)0.40%—0.42%
CPI YoYNot Published—3.7%

Note: Due to the absence of price data for October 2025, the October 2026 CPI year-on-year figure was not published.

02 Background

From $5,500 to $3,900

Gold prices experienced significant volatility this year. In January, gold prices hit a historical high of $5,595 per ounce; thereafter, as markets bet on interest rates remaining at high levels for an extended period, gold prices continued to fall. The London gold average price remained at $4,262 in the third quarter, but by the intraday low of $3,852 on November 12, it had fallen approximately 31% from the January high (calculated).

During this period, the direction of Federal Reserve policy underwent a fundamental shift. Before the end of 2025, the Federal Reserve was still cutting rates, with the federal funds rate cumulatively reduced by 175 basis points from 5.25%–5.50% between July 2023 and September 2024, reaching 3.50%–3.75% by December 2025. For the first five meetings of 2026, rates were held steady. On September 16, the Federal Reserve unanimously voted 12-0 to raise rates by 25 basis points to 3.75%–4.00%, marking the first rate hike since July 2023 and the first policy adjustment under Chairwoman Walsh since she took office in late May. Walsh stated at the press conference that inflation was "too high, and has persisted for too long"; just one week earlier, the European Central Bank had also announced a rate hike. At the July meeting, officials Hamack, Kashkari, and Logan had previously voted in favor of a rate hike, which was ultimately rejected by a vote of 9-3. Trump posted after the September rate hike stating that interest rates should be as low as 1%.

On October 28, the Federal Reserve maintained interest rates unchanged, but the vote was 10-2, with Hamack and Cook voting in favor of a rate hike. The dot plot released in September showed that officials projected the median policy rate to be 4.1% by the end of 2026, implying one more rate hike within the year. MineCube wrote on November 5 that gold prices returned to $4,000 after the midterm elections; just one week later, rate expectations once again overshadowed political factors.

TimeEventFederal Funds Rate
July 2023 – September 2024Held at High Levels5.25%–5.50%
September 2024 – December 2025Cumulative Rate Cuts of 175 bpsReduced to 3.50%–3.75%
January 2026 – July 2026Five Consecutive Meetings Held Steady3.50%–3.75%
September 16, 2026Unanimous 12-0 Vote for 25 bps Hike3.75%–4.00%
October 28, 202610-2 Vote to Hold Rates Steady3.75%–4.00%
December 8–9, 2026Market Expects Another Rate HikeTBD

03 Breakdown

Holding Costs Are Rising

Gold itself does not yield interest, and the opportunity cost of holding it depends on interest rates. On the day the CPI was released, the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield rose to 4.936%, the 2-year yield rose to 4.627%, and the 30-year yield rose to 5.292%. Earlier, on September 28, the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield briefly breached 5.27%, approaching levels seen prior to the 2007 financial crisis.

Interest rate expectations remain on an upward trajectory. J.P. Morgan Private Bank anticipates that the Federal Reserve will raise rates again in December and early 2027, with the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield potentially reaching a peak of 5.25%–5.50%. Analysts at the bank stated that gold would find a solid bottom when interest rates top out. In other words, as long as markets continue to revise their expectations for the terminal rate higher, gold prices lack a clear support level. The World Gold Council had previously noted that when the real yield on 10-year inflation-protected Treasuries approaches 2.5%, the historical opportunity cost of holding gold rises significantly, which may exacerbate outflows from ETFs.

MaturityYield on November 10
2-Year U.S. Treasury4.627%
10-Year U.S. Treasury4.936%
30-Year U.S. Treasury5.292%
10-Year Intraday High on September 28Above 5.27%

The U.S. dollar is also strengthening synchronously. Rising interest rates and uncertainty surrounding the Middle East situation are jointly supporting the dollar, making dollar-denominated gold more expensive for holders of other currencies, further weakening demand. One source driving inflation is energy. Following the outbreak of conflict in the Middle East earlier this year, oil prices surged significantly, and the transmission of energy costs to core inflation has taken longer than expected. During his September press conference, Walsh explained the rise in long-end yields by citing two reasons: a strong economy and global competition for capital, implying that high interest rates may not be a short-term phenomenon.

04 Deconstruction

Physical Demand Has Not Collapsed

It is crucial to distinguish that falling gold prices do not equate to a collapse in gold demand. A report released by the World Gold Council on November 3 showed that total global gold demand in the third quarter was 1,369 tonnes, a year-on-year decline of only 1%; valued at $188 billion, this represents a 22% year-on-year increase. Cumulative demand for the first three quarters reached $566 billion, setting a historical record.

Demand structure showed significant divergence. Central banks were the largest buyers: global central banks net purchased 321 tonnes of gold in the third quarter, a 42% year-on-year increase, marking the highest level since Q4 2024. Cumulative purchases for the first three quarters totaled 675 tonnes, 6% higher than the same period last year; second-quarter purchases were 289 tonnes, also up 62% year-on-year. According to previous central bank surveys by the World Gold Council, a record 45% of responding central banks plan to increase their gold holdings; reported purchases accounted for only 120 tonnes, with approximately 63% coming from unreported purchases. In contrast, demand for bars and coins fell 19% year-on-year to 268 tonnes, the lowest in four years, while jewelry demand declined by 17%.

Demand CategoryQ3 2025Q3 2026YoY Change
Central Banks & Official Institutions226.3 tonnes321.2 tonnes+42%
Bars & Coins—268 tonnes-19%
Jewelry——-17%
Total Demand (incl. OTC)—1,369 tonnes-1%

The World Gold Council has lowered its expectation for investment demand growth in 2026 from 400 tonnes to 200 tonnes, primarily due to weaker bar and coin purchases; simultaneously, it raised its full-year central bank purchase expectation to at least match 2025 levels. This indicates that the forces supporting gold prices have shifted from retail investors to the official sector, where purchases are made for long-term reserves rather than chasing short-term price movements.

ETF performance is also noteworthy. Global gold ETFs saw large-scale inflows in the third quarter. The World Gold Council’s October monthly report indicated that single-month inflows in September reached 67.3 tonnes, worth nearly $10 billion, with cumulative quarterly inflows totaling approximately $31 billion, setting a quarterly record. Investment demand excluding OTC transactions amounted to 479 tonnes, down 14% year-on-year, mainly dragged down by bars and coins; OTC demand was approximately 143 tonnes. On the supply side, recycled gold decreased by 8% year-on-year, indicating that high prices did not bring about increased returns of old gold.

05 Comparison

Wall Street vs. Retail Divergence

Market sentiment divergence is also evident. After gold prices fell below $3,900, a survey of Wall Street professionals showed that the bearish ratio rose to 63%, while bullish sentiment stood at only 6%; among retail investors, the bullish ratio reached 53%, significantly higher than the 30% bearish ratio. Some technical analysts pointed out based on COMEX gold futures trends that $3,900–$4,000 is a support zone formed between October and November last year; if this level is broken, the next key level to watch is $3,500. From a price perspective, with spot gold prices hovering around $3,908, they are already 8.3% lower than the Q3 average of $4,262, suggesting that the Q4 average will likely be significantly lower than the Q3 average.

GroupBullishBearish
Wall Street Respondents6%63%
Retail Respondents53%30%

Another easily overlooked factor is liquidity. During the sharp drop in tech stocks at the end of October, gold prices also fell below $3,900. Market analysis suggests that part of the reason was passive selling triggered by margin calls. When risk assets fall, gold is often sold first to raise cash rather than bought first as a safe haven, which is also the source of the impression that "safe-haven appeal fails."

Historical rate-hiking cycles provide reference points. In December 2015, the Federal Reserve raised rates for the first time in nearly a decade, and gold prices hit a six-year low of approximately $1,046 per ounce the day after the hike, before rising approximately 30% over the following seven months. In 2022, the Fed launched its fastest rate-hiking cycle in forty years; gold prices fell continuously for the first nine months, dropping to approximately $1,618 on November 3. Thereafter, as inflation came in below expectations and the Fed signaled a slowing pace of hikes, gold prices rebounded to $1,741 within the same month and broke through $2,000 in March 2023 following the U.S. banking turmoil.

Rate-Hike CycleGold Price LowBottoming PointSubsequent Performance
2015Approximately $1,046Day after first hikeRose approx. 30% over seven months
2022Approximately $1,618November 3Rose to $1,741 by month-end
2026$3,852 (temporary)November 12To be observed

There is a commonality in both bottoming events: gold prices do not bottom out when interest rates are at their highest, but rather when markets confirm that rate hikes are about to slow or end. In 2015, it was the landing of the first rate-hike "boot"; in 2022, it was falling inflation and the Fed signaling a slowdown. By this pattern, the key to this cycle lies not in whether the Fed raises rates in December, but in how the Fed describes the terminal rate after the hikes.

06 Assessment

Bottom Requires Rates to Top Out

Mineral Cube’s assessment is that the primary driver of this gold price decline is rising holding costs, rather than a failure of its safe-haven appeal. In an environment where the Federal Reserve has resumed rate hikes, with another hike highly likely in December, and the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield hovering near 5%, gold—which generates no interest—is inherently at a disadvantage. As long as markets continue to raise their expectations for the terminal rate, gold prices will struggle to form a sustained rebound.

However, the downside space is constrained by physical demand. Central banks’ gold purchases in the third quarter reached their highest level in nearly two years, with full-year purchase expectations upgraded, indicating that official sectors view the price pullback as an allocation opportunity. China’s physical gold demand in the first three quarters exceeded the total amount of any complete previous year. Third-quarter physical gold demand in China grew 32% year-on-year in value terms, reaching $11 billion. These forces cannot prevent gold prices from falling, but they can slow the pace of the decline, implying that the lower gold prices go, the stronger the support from official and Asian buyers becomes.

For gold prices, the most critical turning signal is the peaking of interest rates. If, after a December rate hike, the Federal Reserve signals a pause, or if inflation data shows a clear decline, gold prices may stabilize around the $3,900 level; however, if the December hike is 50 basis points, or if the dot plot continues to adjust upward the interest rate path for 2027, the support zone near $3,500 will be tested. The futures market is currently not only pricing in a December rate hike but also assigning approximately an 81% probability to another hike by March 2027, pushing the end of the hiking cycle further out.

07 Outlook

Three Signals to Watch for the Bottom

Tracking Point 1: The FOMC Meeting on December 8–9. A 25-basis-point hike has largely been digested by the market; what truly impacts gold prices are the magnitude of the hike, the new dot plot, and Governor Waller’s statements regarding the subsequent path. November CPI data will be released on December 10, one day after the meeting concludes.

Tracking Point 2: Whether the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield can hold above 5%. If the yield breaks through the September high of 5.27% again, gold’s opportunity cost will continue to rise; conversely, a decline in yields would be a leading signal for gold prices to stabilize.

Tracking Point 3: Central bank gold purchases and ETF fund flows. Monitor the World Gold Council’s monthly ETF data and reserve disclosures by various central banks. If central banks accelerate purchases at lower levels, this will provide the strongest support for a price bottom; the gold reserve data published by the People’s Bank of China at the beginning of each month is also an important window for observing official buying activity.

Gold does not fear crises; it fears high interest rates.

— END —