Indonesia Shouts for Quota Cuts, Yet Nickel Prices Do Not Comply
Supply tightening appears imminent,
but quotas are springs, not gates.
| Core Summary ● On October 29, officials from Indonesia’s Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources stated that nickel ore quotas in 2027 will be lower than the revised 290–300 million wet metric tons (WMT) set for 2026; however, quota applications for 2027 have already exceeded 500 million tons. ● The 2026 quota was initially set at approximately 250–270 million tons at the start of the year, with an upward adjustment of 30–40 million tons made mid-year; thus, the reference baseline for “reduction” itself is rising. ● Correction needed for source material: Vale Indonesia produces nickel matte, not nickel concentrate; Q3 production was 18,300 tons, down 5.4% year-on-year but up 13.5% quarter-on-quarter, marking the highest production quarter this year. ● The true reason for pressure on nickel prices is oversupply: The International Nickel Study Group (INSG) revised its 2026 forecast from a deficit to a surplus of 19,000 tons, and expects the 2027 surplus to widen to 70,000 tons, with LME inventory standing at approximately 279,000 tons. ● MineCube Assessment: The 2027 quota will see a “nominal decrease but actual easing”; LME nickel prices in Q4 are likely to oscillate between $14,800–$16,500 per ton. The floor will be supported by smelter production cuts, not quotas. |
|---|
01 Trigger
A weekly decline of 3% to 4%
Nickel prices weakened again last week. According to SMM data, as of October 29, the LME three-month nickel contract closed at $15,515 per ton, down $360 from the previous Friday, representing a decline of approximately 2.3%; the SHFE Ni2612 contract closed at ¥117,190 per ton on October 30, down approximately 2.8% for the week. In the night session on October 30, LME nickel fell another approximately 2%; based on closing prices, the full-week decline is estimated at approximately 4%, which aligns broadly with the source material’s statement of a “3% week-on-week decline.”
| Commodity | Previous Friday | Latest This Week | Weekly Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| LME Three-Month Nickel (USD/ton) | 15,875 | 15,515 | -2.3% |
| SHFE Ni2612 Contract (CNY/ton) | 120,580 | 117,190 | -2.8% |
| High-Nickel Ferronickel Weekly Average Price (CNY/Ni point) | 1,013.7 | 1,011.2 | -2.5 CNY |
| Jinchuan Nickel Premium (CNY/ton) | 4,100 (Monday) | 3,850 (Friday) | -250 CNY |
Note: LME prices reflect the close on October 29; SHFE prices reflect the close on October 30; previous Friday prices are back-calculated from this week’s closing price and weekly decline (estimated); high-nickel ferronickel represents the weekly average price for grades of 10–12%; previous values are back-calculated from the weekly average and weekly change.
The source material attributes the decline in nickel prices to two factors: weak downstream demand and market uncertainty regarding adjustments to Indonesian quotas. Both factors hold true, but a third, more critical factor is omitted—the global nickel market has shifted from “expected shortage” to “confirmed oversupply.” In mid-October, the International Nickel Study Group (INSG) revised its 2026 supply-demand forecast from a deficit of 32,000 tons in April to a surplus of 19,000 tons, and projected that the 2027 surplus would widen to 70,000 tons. This fundamental shift is the root cause of the drop in nickel prices.
Statements from Indonesia occurred on October 28 and 29. Tri Winarno, Director General of Minerals and Coal at Indonesia’s Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, first revealed that potential nickel ore production reflected in 2027 quota applications had already exceeded 500 million tons, with some mining companies yet to submit applications; the following day, he stated that nickel ore quotas in 2027 would be lower than the revised 290–300 million WMT set for 2026, noting that the government needs to conduct a comprehensive assessment to avoid further exacerbating global nickel oversupply.
02 Background
Quotas tug-of-war from 379 million tons downward
To understand Indonesia’s quota signals, one must first examine how they have changed over the past two years. In 2025, Indonesia approved nickel ore quotas of 379 million tons, with actual production reaching approximately 320 million tons. In October 2025, Indonesia changed the quota approval process from every three years to annually, invalidating all previously applied-for 2026 quotas for re-submission. At the beginning of 2026, quotas were significantly reduced to approximately 250–270 million tons (with slight variations across different sources), a decrease of approximately 30% compared to the 2025 approved volume. Consequently, LME nickel prices surged to $18,950, reaching a stage-high of $19,155 in late April.
| Time | Event | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 | Approved quota 379 million tons, actual production approx. 320 million tons | Ample mine-side supply |
| Oct 2025 | Quota approval changed to annual basis | 2026 quotas re-submitted |
| Early 2026 | 2026 quotas compressed to approx. 250–270 million tons | Nickel prices briefly rose to $18,950 |
| Apr 2026 | New HPM pricing rules raised correction coefficients and included co-products | Increased mine-side costs |
| May 2026 | Weda Bay mining area exhausted annual quota and halted production | Raw material shortages |
| Oct 2026 | 2026 quotas revised to approx. 290–300 million tons | Increase of 30–40 million tons from initial levels |
| Oct 29, 2026 | Officials state 2027 quotas will be lower than 2026 revised values | Applications already exceed 500 million tons |
However, this round of “strict control” did not persist until the end. The new benchmark price regulations for nickel ore issued in April raised the correction coefficient for 1.6% grade nickel ore from 17% to 30% and, for the first time, included co-products such as cobalt, iron, and chromium in the pricing formula, triggering strong pushback from Chinese-owned enterprises. Subsequently, the pricing formula underwent downward revisions: the benchmark price for 1.2% grade nickel ore was lowered from $44.97/WMT to $24.89/WMT, and the nickel correction coefficient was reduced from 26% to 14%. In mid-October, Tri Winarno confirmed that the revised 2026 quota was approximately 290 million tons, later providing a range of 290–300 million tons, which is 30–40 million tons higher than the initial target at the start of the year.
This means that the so-called “2027 quota reduction” uses the already-upwardly-adjusted 2026 revised value as the reference baseline, rather than the 250–270 million tons set at the beginning of 2026. Even if the approved volume for 2027 is slightly lower than 290–300 million tons, it is highly likely to remain higher than the early-2026 level. The market is well aware of this, which is one of the reasons why Indonesia’s “quota cut” rhetoric failed to support nickel prices.
03 Breakdown
Why quotas cannot curb oversupply
Quotas cannot curb oversupply for at least three reasons. First, quotas themselves are elastic: additional amounts can be added mid-year, and mining companies repeatedly apply; the 2027 application volume has already exceeded 500 million tons, nearly double the 2026 quota. Second, imports fill the gap: after domestic mines in Indonesia became restricted, smelters turned to purchasing ore from the Philippines. From January to August 2026, Indonesia imported 13.52 million tons of nickel ore from the Philippines, a year-on-year increase of 65.75%. Third, smelting capacity continues to expand: Indonesia’s battery-grade nickel smelting capacity is expected to exceed 900,000 tons of nickel metal content by the end of 2027, roughly double the current level.
| Indicator | 2026 | 2027 |
|---|---|---|
| Global Primary Nickel Demand | Approximately 3.85 million tonnes (YoY +7.6%) | Approximately 4.00 million tonnes |
| Global Primary Nickel Supply | Approximately 3.87 million tonnes | Approximately 4.07 million tonnes |
| Supply-Demand Balance | Surplus of approximately 19,000 tonnes | Surplus of approximately 70,000 tonnes |
| April 2026 Forecast | Deficit of approximately 32,000 tonnes | — |
Note: Forecasts in the table are from the International Nickel Study Group (INSG) mid-October estimates.
The demand side has also offered no surprises. The INSG noted that while demand in the stainless steel sector is growing, the uptake of nickel in electric vehicle batteries is increasing more slowly than expected due to competition from lithium iron phosphate (LFP) batteries. On the inventory front, LME nickel stocks stood at approximately 279,000 tonnes on October 28, remaining at elevated levels; domestic social inventories of nickel sheets were approximately 124,400 tonnes on October 30, representing a weekly increase of approximately 2.1%. Although stainless steel futures inventories have declined for three consecutive weeks to approximately 549,000 tonnes, this is primarily attributable to reduced arrivals and end-of-month withdrawals rather than an improvement in demand. High inventories combined with weak demand suggest that the bullish impact of quota cuts is unlikely to sustain momentum.
Another detail worth noting is that the INSG’s 2026 production forecast was revised upward by approximately 150,000 tonnes compared to April, indicating that the tightening of quotas this year has not resulted in an actual reduction in output; instead, production growth has outpaced expectations. Quotas act more as a lever that raises costs rather than a gate restricting supply: they have driven up ore prices and smelting costs, but have failed to genuinely contract the supply of refined nickel metal.
04 Breakdown
Vale Indonesia: Production Cut or Recovery?
The source material mentions “Vale Indonesia’s third-quarter nickel concentrate production fell 6% year-on-year,” which requires correction. Vale Indonesia (PT Vale Indonesia) produces nickel matte (nickel sulfide) at its Sorowako facility in Sulawesi, which is an intermediate product containing approximately 78% nickel, not nickel concentrate. According to data released by the company on October 30, nickel metal production contained in nickel matte during the third quarter was 18,341 tonnes, a decline of approximately 5.4% (calculated) from 19,391 tonnes in the same period last year, rather than 6%.
| Indicator | Value |
|---|---|
| Q3 2026 Nickel Matte Production | 18,341 tonnes (YoY -5.4%, QoQ +13.5%) |
| Q2 2026 Nickel Matte Production | 16,153 tonnes |
| Q3 2025 Nickel Matte Production | 19,391 tonnes |
| H1-H3 2026 Nickel Matte Production | 48,114 tonnes (YoY -12.5%) |
| Full-Year 2026 Production Target | 67,645 tonnes |
| Required Q4 Production | Approximately 19,531 tonnes (calculated) |
| Q3 Realized Average Price of Nickel Matte | $14,053/tonne (Q2: $14,765) |
| Q3 Unit Cash Selling Cost | $10,404/tonne (Q2: $10,005) |
| Q3 Nickel Ore Sales Volume | Approximately 1.73 million wet metric tons |
Note: Year-on-year, quarter-on-quarter figures, and required Q4 production are calculated by Kuanglifang.
More importantly, consider the trend. The 18,341 tonnes produced in Q3 represents a 13.5% increase from Q2, making it the highest production quarter of 2026. The 12.5% year-on-year decline in production for the first three quarters was mainly dragged down by major maintenance at the beginning of the year and the reconstruction of Electric Furnace No. 3; production has already rebounded following the completion of the furnace reconstruction in June. Thus, Vale Indonesia’s production decline was caused by maintenance, not a signal of voluntary production cuts. To achieve the full-year target of 67,645 tonnes, approximately 19,531 tonnes must be produced in Q4, representing a further increase of approximately 6.5% (calculated) over Q3.
Vale Indonesia’s dynamics are shifting in another direction: ore sales. In Q3, the company sold approximately 1.73 million wet metric tons of nickel ore across two blocks, Bahodopi and Pomalaa, with Pomalaa accounting for approximately 1.31 million wet metric tons and Bahodopi for approximately 415,000 wet metric tons. This generated revenue of $353 million, marking a quarter-on-quarter increase. Net profit for the first three quarters reached $147 million, a year-on-year increase of approximately 180%; however, net profit for Q3 alone was $42.75 million, lower than the $60.77 million recorded in Q2. Increased consumption of fuel oil (+6%) and coal (+12%) in Q3 drove up smelting costs. During a period of tightening nickel ore quotas in Indonesia and high ore premiums, selling ore became a significant source of profit. With the realized price of nickel matte dropping to $14,053/tonne in Q3 and unit cash costs rising to $10,404/tonne, the profit margin for the nickel matte business is narrowing.
05 Comparison
Smelters Face Pressure Before Miners
If quotas represent government control over mining, then losses at the smelting end may be what truly contracts supply. According to Reuters reports, around October 20, Chinese-owned nickel enterprises operating in Indonesia held meetings to discuss coordinated production cuts. Proposed measures included halving Hydrous Nickel Cobalt Hydroxide (MHP) production and reducing Nickel Pig Iron (NPI) production by approximately 20%, though neither the scale nor the duration was finalized. Nickel Industries, located in the Morowali Industrial Park in Indonesia, stated that companies within the park would coordinate production cuts, with its own NPI production in October already reduced to approximately 75% of capacity.
| Item | Content | Status |
|---|---|---|
| MHP | Discussion of ~50% production cut | Not finalized |
| Nickel Pig Iron (NPI) | Discussion of ~20% production cut | Not finalized |
| Nickel Industries NPI | Operating rate of ~75% in October | Implemented |
| Previous August Discussions | Each enterprise cutting ~30% | No consensus reached |
Pressure on the smelting end stems from several directions: falling nickel prices, shortages of sulfur driving up hydrometallurgical smelting costs, widening discounts on cobalt compressing by-product revenues for MHP, and water scarcity caused by El Niño. The price of NPI has fallen from above 1,100 RMB per nickel point in early September to around 1,010 RMB per nickel point. In late October, the Indonesian nickel ore pricing reference (HMA) dropped to $15,847.67/tonne, a 2.91% quarter-on-quarter decrease. On October 30, the FOB price for Indonesian MHP was approximately $13,044/tonne of nickel, falling by another $98 that day. Previously, the Indonesian Nickel Smelter Association estimated that due to raw material shortages, high ore prices, drought, and water scarcity, Indonesia’s nickel product output would decline by 3.5% to 4% this year. As cost support from the mining end moves downward, smelting profits have not improved accordingly.
However, the market remains skeptical about production cuts. Some research institutions pointed out that based on cost structure calculations, even if cuts occur, the magnitude may be smaller than rumored. On October 21, LME nickel rose 4.1% in a single day to $16,310, hitting a three-week high, driven by cut expectations, but quickly gave back those gains. This highlights the fragility of price support without concrete implementation. Compared to the Indonesian government’s statements on quotas, the actual losses incurred by smelters constitute a more genuine driver for production cuts, but it will take time for these effects to materialize.
06 Assessment
Quotas Nominal Reduction, Actual Ease
Mineral Cube’s assessment is that Indonesia’s 2027 nickel ore quota will likely see a “nominal reduction but actual easing”: the approved total volume will be lower than the revised 290–300 million tonnes for 2026, but it will most likely remain higher than the approximately 250–270 million tonnes at the beginning of 2026. Coupled with mid-year additions and imports from the Philippines, a genuine shortage in the mining sector is unlikely to materialize. In the fourth quarter, LME nickel prices are expected to oscillate within the $14,800–$16,500 range; the lower bound is supported by smelter production cuts, while the upper bound is suppressed by high inventory levels.
First, Indonesia has the motivation to reduce quotas but lacks the capacity to push them down significantly. Indonesian smelters require approximately 320 million tonnes of nickel ore annually, while the government also aims to expand downstream industries and attract more investment. If quotas are cut too severely, it would primarily damage Indonesia’s own smelting industry. This was already demonstrated by the upward revision earlier this year.
Second, the direction of nickel prices is determined by oversupply, not by quotas. The International Nickel Study Group (INSG) projects that the global surplus will widen to 70,000 tonnes in 2027, with LME inventories nearing 280,000 tonnes. These factors cannot be reversed by mere statements regarding quota allocations. For nickel prices to truly break out from their bottom, substantial production cuts on the smelting side or unexpected growth in demand must occur; currently, neither has happened.
Third, the downside space is limited. On October 15, LME nickel prices fell to an annual low of $14,885. This level has pushed many Indonesian smelters into losses, sparking discussions about production cuts near this price point. The deeper the price falls, the greater the likelihood that production cuts will be implemented, providing a relatively clear floor for nickel prices.
07 Outlook
Three signals to watch for the direction of nickel prices
Tracking Point 1: Total approved volume of the 2027 quota. The application window for the 2027 quota runs from October 1 to November 15. At the beginning of October, Indonesia’s Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources stated that approvals would be expedited this year, aiming to issue quotas before the statutory deadline, and promised fairer distribution. If the total approved volume drops significantly below 290 million tonnes—for example, returning to around 260 million tonnes—and no further additions are made during the year, nickel prices may have the opportunity to retest $16,500. Conversely, if the approved volume approaches or exceeds 290 million tonnes, expectations of “quota cuts” will be completely dashed.
Tracking Point 2: Whether production cuts at the Morowali Industrial Park are implemented. Monitor whether Chinese-funded enterprises announce specific production cut ratios and execution timelines, as well as the actual output of nickel pig iron (NPI) and Mixed Hydroxide Precipitate (MHP) in Indonesia in November. If production cuts are realized, NPI prices should stabilize above RMB 1,000 per nickel point and recover. If production cuts are delayed indefinitely, the risk of NPI prices falling below RMB 1,000 per nickel point will increase.
Tracking Point 3: LME inventories and domestic nickel sheet inventories. If LME nickel inventories begin to decline continuously from approximately 279,000 tonnes, and social inventories of domestic nickel sheets stop accumulating, it indicates that supply and demand are beginning to improve. Conversely, if LME inventories rise back above 285,000 tonnes and domestic inventories continue to increase, nickel prices may once again test the $14,800 level.
Quotas determine ore prices; oversupply determines nickel prices.
— END —