Indonesia’s Nickel Ore Applications Double: What Happens to Nickel Prices?
Indonesia’s nickel ore applications double; what is the impact on nickel prices?
The appearance of a flood of capacity expansion masks the reality that quotas remain the master valve.
| Core Summary ● On October 28, Tri Winarno, Director General of Minerals and Coal at Indonesia’s Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM), stated that the nickel ore production volume applied for by mining companies for 2027 has exceeded 500 million wet metric tons (WMT), with some enterprises yet to submit their applications. The application window closes on November 15. ● The term “double” depends on the baseline: compared to the initial approval of 260–270 million WMT in early 2026, it is approximately double; compared to the revised figure of 290–300 million WMT mid-year, it is approximately 1.7 times higher (estimated). ● Application volume does not equal approved volume: Indonesian authorities have explicitly stated that the 2027 quota will be lower than the 2026 revised value. On November 4, they indicated that the reduction might be “more aggressive” than in 2026, a stance publicly supported by the National Economic Council. ● The supply chain is already under pressure: On October 30, quotes for Indonesian MHP nickel and cobalt, as well as high-grade nickel matte, were cut across the board; the International Nickel Study Group (INSG) forecasts a surplus of 19,000 tons in 2026, expanding to 70,000 tons in 2027; North American nickel-cobalt refiner Sherritt temporarily laid off 47% of its Canadian workforce due to sanctions on Cuba. ● MineCube Assessment: The 500 million ton figure is a “wish list,” not actual supply. The 2027 RKAB (Work Plan and Budget) is highly likely to fall within the range of 260–290 million WMT. The LME nickel price floor is expected to hold at $15,000/ton, with the approved quota volume being the sole variable determining the height of this bottom. |
|---|
01 The Trigger
Where did the 500 million ton application volume come from?
On October 28, Tri Winarno, Director General of Minerals and Coal at Indonesia’s Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM), announced that the nickel ore mining volume applied for by Indonesian mining companies for 2027 has exceeded 500 million wet metric tons (WMT), with some enterprises yet to submit their applications. According to current regulations, the application window for the Annual Work Plan and Budget (RKAB) runs from October 1 to November 15 each year. Upon news breaking, the market’s first reaction was that “Indonesia is loosening the tap.”
However, this number must be viewed in the correct coordinate system. The 2026 quota underwent one revision: the total initially approved at the beginning of the year was approximately 260–270 million WMT. On October 29, Tri Winarno confirmed that the revised 2026 quota had been raised to approximately 290–300 million WMT. The material claiming the 500 million tons is “approximately double the 2026 quota” is comparing against the initial approval value; if compared to the revised quota, 500 million tons is approximately 1.7 times higher (estimated). More importantly, the same official explicitly stated on October 29 that the 2027 quota will be lower than the post-revision level of 2026.
| Metric | Volume (Wet Tons) | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 Approved Quota | Approx. 379 million | Source: Indonesian Business Post |
| 2026 Initial Approval | Approx. 260–270 million | Announced in February |
| 2026 Revised Quota | Approx. 290–300 million | Officially confirmed on October 29 |
| 2026 Actual Production Estimate | Approx. 290 million | ESDM estimate in early October |
| 2027 Application Volume | Exceeds 500 million | As of October 28, some enterprises have not applied |
| 2027 Official Stance | Lower than 2026 revised value | Statement made on October 29 |
Note: Different institutions show significant discrepancies in statistics for 2025 approved volumes and actual production; the figures in the table represent representative values from public reports.
02 Background
From Loose Quotas to Tightening
Indonesia is the world’s largest nickel producer. Since banning exports of raw nickel ore in 2020, nickel ore can only be sold to domestic smelters, making the quota system the “master valve” regulating global nickel supply. In 2025, Indonesia approved a nickel ore quota of approximately 379 million WMT, creating ample supply that suppressed nickel prices. At the beginning of 2026, Indonesia significantly compressed the quota to 260–270 million WMT with the intent of stabilizing prices. Septian Hario Seto, a member of the Indonesian National Economic Council, noted on November 3 that after the ESDM announced the first round of quota reductions, nickel prices rose nearly 20%.
However, this tightening did not last until the end of the year. Due to shortages of raw materials for smelters, Indonesia increased the quota mid-year, ultimately revising it to 290–300 million WMT. The Indonesian Nickel Smelting Association estimates that domestic nickel product output in 2026 will decline by 3.5%–4%, affected by raw material shortages, rising ore prices, drought-induced water restrictions, and power allocation issues at some smelters. While quota tightening did curb supply, it also left smelters underfed, which serves as the starting point for 2027 quota negotiations.
| Time | Official Statement |
|---|---|
| October 6 | ESDM: 2027 RKAB approval will be faster, with fairer quota allocation |
| October 28 | 2027 application volume exceeds 500 million WMT; some enterprises have not applied |
| October 29 | 2027 quota will be lower than the revised 290–300 million WMT of 2026 |
| November 3 | National Economic Council supports reducing production via RKAB to address oversupply |
| November 4 | ESDM: 2027 reduction may be more aggressive than in 2026 |
The statement on November 4 is the most critical. Cecep Mochammad Yasin, Director of Mining Business Development at the ESDM, stated that the 2027 quota will be determined based on the “optimal operating capacity” of domestic smelters, rather than merely meeting their raw material needs. ESDM Minister Bahlil Lahadalia added that Indonesia plans to adopt a supply management approach for nickel similar to that used for coal. The figure provided by Bahlil is that global nickel demand is approximately 3.5 million tons annually, with an oversupply nearing 800,000 tons.
03 Breakdown
Why are applications double the quota?
Application volumes far exceeding quotas is nothing new in Indonesia. Mining companies tend to over-report for two reasons: first, to reserve negotiation space for securing larger shares; second, because they observe that smelting capacity continues to expand. The ESDM previously required nickel mining companies to submit next year’s production plans in advance, allowing them to assess smelter raw material needs and upstream capacity before approval. In other words, the 500 million tons reflects how much ore smelting capacity wants, not how much the government is prepared to approve.
The real constraint lies in the mismatch between capacity and demand. Major global nickel producers, facing high inventory and oversupply pressures, have begun considering contraction: reports indicate that major producers such as Huayou and Tsingshan are considering production cuts of up to 50%, though no cuts have been confirmed. Additionally, reports suggest Indonesia is considering suspending the construction of new smelters producing nickel intermediate products. These signals form a sharp contrast with the “doubling of application volumes”: upstream players want to mine more, midstream players want to produce less, and the government stands in the middle making choices.
| Institution | 2026 | 2027 |
|---|---|---|
| INSG: Production | 3.87 million tons | 4.07 million tons |
| INSG: Demand | 3.85 million tons | 4.00 million tons |
| INSG: Surplus | 19,000 tons | 70,000 tons |
| S&P Global CERA: Surplus | 79,000 tons | 30,000 tons |
| Indonesian ESDM Minister’s Figure: Surplus | Nearing 800,000 tons | — |
Note: The International Nickel Study Group (INSG) reports on primary nickel balance. Indonesia’s official figure of an 800,000-tonne surplus does not disclose its calculation methodology, so the two figures are not directly comparable.
The divergence in surplus estimates is itself a signal. On October 13, the INSG revised its 2026 outlook from a deficit of 32,000 tonnes to a surplus of 19,000 tonnes, and projected that the surplus would widen to 70,000 tonnes in 2027; the Indonesian official estimate of an 800,000-tonne surplus is significantly larger. There is a motive for officials to emphasize oversupply, as this provides justification for reducing quotas. Simultaneously, the INSG forecasts that global primary nickel demand will reach approximately 3.85 million tonnes in 2026, representing a year-on-year increase of 7.6%, with the stainless steel sector continuing to expand in the second half of the year and into 2027. However, nickel demand growth for power batteries has slowed below expectations due to competition from lithium iron phosphate (LFP) batteries.
04 Deconstruction
The Industry Chain Is Under Pressure
Price pressure is tangible. LME nickel prices fell to $15,252 per tonne on October 15, marking the lowest level since December 2025. From October 1 to 12, the LME spot average price was approximately $15,508 per tonne, which is 17.5% lower than the May average. Intermediate products weakened synchronously: according to data from SMM (Shanghai Metals Market), on October 30, the FOB price for Indonesian MHP nickel fell by $98 per nickel tonne compared to the previous day; MHP cobalt fell by $358 per cobalt tonne, and ferronickel fell by $107 per nickel tonne.
| Indicator | Value | Time |
|---|---|---|
| LME Nickel Price Period Low | $15,252/tonne | October 15 |
| LME Spot Average Price | ~$15,508/tonne (-17.5% vs. May average) | October 1–12 |
| Indonesian MHP Nickel FOB | $15,337/nickel tonne | August 6 |
| Indonesian MHP Nickel FOB | $14,993/nickel tonne | August 31 |
| Indonesian MHP Cobalt FOB | $49,106→$35,915/cobalt tonne | August 6→August 31 |
| Single-Day Change in MHP Nickel/Cobalt/Ferronickel | -$98/-$358/-$107 | October 30 |
The decline in cobalt was particularly pronounced. Between August 6 and August 31, the FOB price for Indonesian MHP cobalt dropped from $49,106 per cobalt tonne to $35,915, a decrease of approximately 27% (calculated). The pricing coefficient for MHP cobalt fell from 91 to 70. This indicates that hydrometallurgical projects relying on cobalt revenue to amortize costs are seeing their profit margins compressed. On November 5, influenced by the US midterm elections and statements regarding Indonesian quotas, SHFE nickel prices rose nearly 5% during midday trading, indicating that market sentiment remains highly sensitive to expectations of "quota tightening."
Inventory is another mountain weighing down nickel prices. According to public reports, combined LME and SHFE nickel inventories reached approximately 469,000 tonnes at mid-year, setting a record. S&P Global CERA noted during the LME week that LME nickel spot prices were only slightly above the year-to-date lows, with Rotterdam physical premiums facing downward pressure. Following Weda Bay's announcement of production resumption, CERA lowered its forecast for the average LME three-month nickel price in 2026 from $17,548 to $17,311. CERA also highlighted that new HPAL capacity coming online in Indonesia from late 2026 into 2027 will be primarily used to produce Class 1 nickel, potentially increasing exchange deliveries; however, sulfur shortages may delay some new projects.
Regarding the claim in source materials that "MHP nickel, cobalt, and ferronickel quotes were all adjusted downward on November 2," the most recent verifiable instance of a comprehensive downward adjustment we found was the quote on October 30. Specific data for November 2 has not yet been located in independently verifiable sources; therefore, the main text relies on the October 30 data.
05 Comparison
Sherritt: A Case Study Under Sanctions
The Sherritt case supplemented in the source material provides another sample of "supply contraction." On November 4, Canadian nickel and cobalt producer Sherritt announced it would temporarily lay off approximately 280 employees, representing 47% of its total Canadian workforce, for a period of approximately 90 days. The objective is to maintain liquidity while restoring refining operations. Sherritt’s Fort Saskatchewan refinery in Alberta sources raw materials from the Moa joint venture mine in Cuba. It is the only large-scale cobalt refinery in North America and one of only three nickel refineries in the region.
| Time | Event |
|---|---|
| May 1, 2026 | US Executive Order expands sanctions scope against Cuba, covering mining and other sectors |
| May 7, 2026 | Sherritt suspends direct participation in activities of the Cuban joint venture |
| June 22, 2026 | Raw materials at the Fort Saskatchewan refinery are depleted, halting metal refining |
| October 19, 2026 | Obtains the first emergency license from the US Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) |
| November 4, 2026 | Temporary layoff of approximately 280 people, constituting 47% of Canadian staff, for a duration of about 90 days |
Sherritt’s volume is insufficient to alter the global nickel balance, but it illustrates a key point: supply risk in nickel has shifted from "whether there is enough ore" to "whether policy permits extraction." Whether it is Indonesian quotas or US sanctions against Cuba, government decisions are increasingly determining supply rather than geological conditions. Sherritt stated that additional licenses are still required to resume mining and processing in Cuba and refining in Canada. Fertilizer and sulfuric acid production continued during the layoff period.
Sherritt and Cuba’s state-owned General Nickel Company have each held 50% of the shares in the Moa joint venture since 1994. In February this year, following the interruption of oil shipments from Venezuela to Cuba, Moa was forced to reduce production due to fuel shortages. On the day it announced the suspension of participation in the Cuban joint venture in May, Sherritt’s stock price plummeted by approximately 30%. This company’s experience serves as a reminder that within North American critical mineral supply chains, a portion of raw materials actually originates from sanctioned countries.
06 Assessment
Quotas Determine the Nickel Price Floor
Kuangye Fang’s assessment is that the 500-million-tonne application volume represents a "wish list" rather than actual supply; the 2027 RKAB (Work Plan and Budget) is likely to fall between 260 million and 290 million wet metric tonnes. Within this range, the LME nickel price floor is expected to hold at $15,000 per tonne, with higher floors corresponding to approved volumes closer to the lower end of the range.
First, policy signals are highly consistent. Statements from the Director-General of Mineral and Coal Affairs, the Director of Mining Business Development, the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, and the National Economic Council since late October all point toward "reduced approvals in 2027." Indonesian officials have even applied coal-style supply management to nickel, meaning quotas are evolving from administrative approval tools into price management instruments.
Second, the upper limit of tightening is constrained by smelting capacity. The 2026 quota was raised from 260–270 million tonnes to 290–300 million tonnes precisely because smelters faced raw material shortages. If approvals for 2027 are too tight, the operating rates of Indonesian smelters will decline, leading to increased imports of nickel ore (primarily from the Philippines). Consequently, the government may ultimately revise quotas again mid-year. This is why we believe quotas will not fall below 260 million wet metric tonnes. The INSG’s base case assumes that imported ores will continue to support Indonesia’s production growth, thereby deriving the projected 70,000-tonne surplus for 2027.
Third, the demand side provides no additional support. The substitution of ternary batteries by lithium iron phosphate (LFP) batteries continues. Stainless steel remains the primary consumer of nickel; its growth is steady but insufficient to absorb the surplus. The LME nickel price hit a low of $15,252 in mid-October, marking the lowest level since December 2025. This price level has already been tested once during the downward trend. The direction of nickel prices is determined by supply policies, while the pace is dictated by statements from Indonesian officials. This constitutes the most significant characteristic of the nickel market in 2027.
07 Outlook
Three Key Nodes for Nickel Prices
Tracking Point 1: Final application volumes after the November 15 deadline.
Following the deadline, will authorities publish the total volume of applications, and will they provide an initial range for 2027 quotas? If the range provided by authorities is below 270 million wet metric tons, nickel prices are expected to rebound above $16,000. If it exceeds 300 million tons, the support at $15,000 will face testing.
Tracking Point 2: The timing and allocation method for 2027 quotas.
The 2026 quotas were announced on February 10. Following this rhythm, the 2027 quotas are highly likely to be finalized in the first quarter, a period when the Philippines experiences its rainy season and nickel ore supply is seasonally tight. For example, in 2025, only 17 vessels loaded nickel ore from the Surigao region in the Philippines in November, compared to 126 vessels in October. Monitor whether quotas favor integrated smelting projects and whether mid-year revisions are permitted.
Tracking Point 3: Actual production cuts by major smelters.
Production cuts by companies such as Huayou and Tsingshan currently remain at the "consideration" stage. Once implemented, the supply of nickel pig iron (NPI) and mixed hydroxide precipitate (MHP) will contract ahead of quota reductions, with intermediate product prices stabilizing first. Additionally, monitor whether Indonesia implements the proposal to suspend the construction of new nickel intermediate smelting plants, which will determine the capacity ceiling post-2028. For trading and downstream enterprises, prior to the finalization of quotas, it is advisable to prioritize short-term contracts and batch purchasing to avoid locking in long-term high or low prices during policy windows.
The volume applied for does not count; only the volume approved matters.
— END —