Lithium Carbonate Crashes Again, This Time Led by Investment Banks

What appears to be a short-term oversold condition is actually the beginning of an overcapacity cycle.

Core Summary ● Citigroup’s report on October 30 lowered target prices for lithium carbonate and lithium hydroxide for the next three months from $20,000/tonne and $17,000/tonne to $12,000/tonne, respectively, and reduced spodumene targets from $2,000/tonne to $1,200/tonne, while simultaneously downgrading forecasts through the end of 2028. ● On November 2, the main contract for lithium carbonate on the Guangzhou Futures Exchange traded at 91,160 RMB/tonne, marking a cumulative decline of over 40% since late August; this represents a halving from the highs above 200,000 RMB seen in mid-May. On November 5, intraday prices briefly rebounded 6% to 93,680 RMB. ● Citigroup’s $12,000 target is nearly identical to the current spot price excluding tax (calculated); this price cut resembles “stamping approval” on already realized declines rather than predicting a new wave of crashes. ● The basis for overcapacity is tangible: Rio Tinto’s two new projects in Argentina came online in Q2, adding 25,000 tonnes of lithium carbonate equivalent (LCE) capacity; domestic lithium carbonate production reached 117,700 tonnes in October, with November scheduled production at 121,800 tonnes, while port lithium ore inventories rose to 404,000 tonnes. ● Mineral Cube Assessment: Lithium prices have entered the first half of the overcapacity cycle, with bottom-grinding expected to dominate through H1 2027; a true reversal requires the clearance of high-cost capacity and delays in new projects. Benchmark’s calculation of “134 new mines and $100 billion” represents long-term logic, not next year’s logic.

01 Trigger

Citigroup slashes prices by 40% in one go

On November 2, Bloomberg reported that Citigroup significantly lowered its lithium price forecasts in a report released on October 30, citing slowing battery demand growth, rising trade uncertainties, and broader macroeconomic headwinds. Citigroup reduced its three-month target price for lithium carbonate from $20,000/tonne to $12,000/tonne, lithium hydroxide from $17,000/tonne to $12,000/tonne, and spodumene concentrate from $2,000/tonne to $1,200/tonne, while also downgrading all forecasts for these three raw materials through the end of 2028. Citigroup believes that concerns over deteriorating demand next year have triggered a "lithium market reset." With supply improvements expected in 2027 and uncertain demand next year, buyers are inclined to delay purchases and maintain low inventory levels. In the short term, sentiment and positioning will dominate prices, with risks skewed to the downside.

CommodityOriginal Target PriceNew Target PriceDecline
Lithium Carbonate (3 months)$20,000/tonne$12,000/tonne-40%
Lithium Hydroxide (3 months)$17,000/tonne$12,000/tonne-29.4% (calculated)
Spodumene Concentrate (3 months)$2,000/tonne$1,200/tonne-40%

The futures market had already moved ahead. The most actively traded lithium carbonate contract on the Guangzhou Futures Exchange rose 1.2% in early trading on November 2, reporting at 91,160 RMB/tonne, approximately $13,710. However, the cumulative decline since late August has exceeded 40%. The narrative of "a 40% drop in two months" aligns with Bloomberg’s figures. On November 5, the main lithium carbonate contract intraday surged 6% to 93,680 RMB/tonne, indicating significantly increased divergence between bulls and bears near the 90,000 RMB level.

Spot price declines were slightly less severe than futures but followed the same direction. According to SMM data, the average spot price for battery-grade lithium carbonate on October 12 was 115,400 RMB/tonne, falling 6,950 RMB in a single day. According to Mysteel data, battery-grade lithium carbonate fell 3,500 RMB in a single day on October 29 to 92,000–98,800 RMB/tonne, and on November 3 it traded at 91,400–95,900 RMB/tonne. Notably, in June of this year, Citigroup stated in a research report on CATL that short-term lithium carbonate prices above $200,000/tonne would not destroy demand, arguing that higher lithium prices were actually proof of robust demand. In less than five months, the judgment of the same investment bank shifted from "high prices are proof of strong demand" to "lithium market reset," illustrating the speed of market sentiment shifts.

02 Background

From 200,000 to 90,000 in Half a Year

Looking at the timeline more broadly, this round of declines began in the middle of the year. On May 13, the main lithium carbonate contract closed at 201,960 RMB/tonne, with battery-grade lithium carbonate spot quotes ranging between 198,000 and 203,000 RMB, and 6% spodumene concentrate quoted at $2,945/tonne. By July 1, the main contract had fallen back to 164,560 RMB. In mid-August, it fluctuated around 150,000 RMB, briefly rebounding above 160,000 RMB in late August. The acceleration of the decline occurred in October: on October 12, the main contract plummeted 11.79% in a single day, closing at 104,740 RMB, breaking below 110,000 RMB for the first time since December 2025. By October 29, it further broke below 90,000 RMB.

DateMain Contract (RMB/tonne)Context
May 13, 2026201,960In-year high range
July 1, 2026164,560High-level pullback
August 13, 2026151,420Peak season rebound expectations
October 12, 2026104,740Single-day drop of 11.79%
November 2, 202691,160Down more than 40% from late August
Intraday Nov 5, 202693,680Single-day rebound of 6%

Lithium ores fell just as sharply. 6% spodumene concentrate was quoted at $2,945/tonne on May 13, dropped to $2,080 on August 11, and by late October, the CIF China price for Australian spodumene concentrate had fallen to $1,350–$1,380/tonne. Citigroup’s new target price of $1,200 implies that spodumene still has about a 10% downside space (calculated). For African and some Australian mines with costs above $1,000, this is already approaching cash cost lines.

Date6% Spodumene Concentrate Price
May 13, 2026$2,945/tonne
August 11, 2026$2,080/tonne
Late October 2026$1,350–$1,380/tonne (Australian mine CIF China)
Citigroup 3-month Target$1,200/tonne

03 Breakdown

Which segment did Citigroup cut?

Understanding Citigroup’s price cut hinges on the basis of calculation. Citigroup provides dollar-denominated target prices for the next three months, whereas the Guangzhou Futures Exchange quotes are in RMB including a 13% value-added tax (VAT). Using Bloomberg’s conversion method, 91,160 RMB/tonne is approximately $13,710; after deducting VAT, the ex-tax price is approximately 80,670 RMB, translating to roughly $12,130 (calculated). Therefore, Citigroup’s new target of $12,000 is essentially equal to the current ex-tax spot level. This downward adjustment is more about pulling old target prices back to market rates rather than predicting another 40% drop in lithium prices.

What truly matters is the direction, not the magnitude. Citi’s previous $20,000 target price corresponded to market expectations of "destocking during the peak season"; now, its target price aligns with the current spot price, and it has simultaneously downgraded forecasts through the end of 2028, effectively acknowledging that there will not be sufficient demand over the next two years to absorb new supply. Citi believes the market will first return to balance before entering a period of oversupply.

Demand-side data is indeed weakening. Data from the China Passenger Car Association (CPCA) shows that domestic retail sales of new energy passenger vehicles in September reached 1.084 million units, a year-on-year decline of 16.7%; cumulative sales from January to September were 7.758 million units, down 12.8% year-on-year. It should be noted that this figure reflects domestic retail metrics; according to the China Association of Automobile Manufacturers (CAAM), including exports, new energy vehicle sales from January to September still grew by 11.1% year-on-year, with exports serving as the primary pillar supporting total volume. Energy storage is another key pillar, but the market is beginning to question the sustainability of energy storage orders for next year, with reports suggesting some battery manufacturers are reducing their production schedules. Additionally, potential EU quotas on Chinese plug-in hybrid vehicles are viewed by the market as bearish.

04 Breakdown

Supply is being released in concentrated batches.

The supply increments specifically highlighted by Citi are two new projects by Rio Tinto in Catamarca Province, Argentina. On October 28, Rio Tinto held commissioning ceremonies for the Fenix 1B expansion and the Sal de Vida project. With a combined investment of approximately $1.4 billion, both projects achieved initial production ahead of schedule in the second quarter. Upon reaching full capacity, they will add an annual output of 25,000 metric tons of lithium carbonate equivalent (LCE). Specifically, Fenix 1B adds 10,000 tons, utilizing direct lithium extraction technology, while Sal de Vida has a designed capacity of 15,000 tons, employing traditional salt pond evaporation processes. Rio Tinto aims to achieve an annual capacity of 200,000 tons of LCE by 2028. In the first half of this year, Rio Tinto’s lithium production was 27,300 tons of LCE, representing a year-on-year increase of 53%; when including projects such as Olaroz, its nominal capacity in Argentina is approximately 100,000 tons. The Argentine Secretariat of Mining estimates that the country’s lithium production could surpass Chile’s by 2029, reaching 573,000 tons annually by 2035.

Project/EventScaleProgress
Rio Tinto Fenix 1B (Argentina)Additional 10,000 tons LCE/yearInitial production in Q2, ramping up
Rio Tinto Sal de Vida (Argentina)15,000 tons LCE/yearInitial production in Q2, ramping up
Rio Tinto Lithium Business Target200,000 tons LCE/year by 2028In progress
Yichun Jianxiawo Lithium MineDesigned mining capacity of 30 million tons/yearEIA approval granted
Jiangxi Qiankeng Lithium MineTheoretical capacity of approx. 15,000 tons LCE/yearSafety facility design passed review
Sinomine Resources Zimbabwe Lithium Sulfate Plant100,000 tons/yearPlanned for commissioning within the year

Changes in domestic supply are more direct. The Jianxiawo Lithium Mine, owned by CATL subsidiary Yichun, halted production in August, which had been a significant factor driving up lithium prices; in October, its environmental impact assessment was re-accepted and approved, leading market expectations that the world’s largest single lepidolite mine will resume production. Later that month, the safety facility design for the 3 million ton/year mining engineering project at Jiangxi Qiankeng Lithium Mine passed review, and shipments of Zimbabwean lithium concentrate are gradually resuming.

IndicatorValueChange
Domestic lithium carbonate production in October117,700 tonsMoM +2.7%
Domestic lithium carbonate production schedule for November121,800 tonsMoM +3.5%
Domestic port lithium ore inventory404,000 tonsMoM +12,000 tons
New energy passenger vehicle retail sales in September1.084 million unitsYoY -16.7%
Cumulative new energy passenger vehicle retail sales Jan–Sep7.758 million unitsYoY -12.8%

Production is increasing, production schedules are rising, and port lithium ore inventories are accumulating, while terminal retail sales are declining year-on-year; this is the typical combination of an oversupply cycle. Notably, according to Mysteel statistics, total lithium carbonate inventory across all categories dropped to 113,600 tons by the end of September, a cumulative decrease of approximately 44%. Some institutions believe destocking continues into the fourth quarter, characterizing this round of declines with the phrase "reality has not collapsed, expectations have led." However, futures trading reflects next year’s conditions, where supply increments are certain, but demand growth rates are uncertain.

05 Comparison

Long-term deficit vs. short-term oversupply

The reversal points mentioned in materials are verifiable. Benchmark Mineral Intelligence released calculations in October estimating that global lithium demand will increase by approximately 4.8 million tons of LCE between 2026 and 2050. Based on a single mine producing 36,000 tons annually, this equates to the need for 134 new lithium mines, requiring investments exceeding $100 billion without considering recycling; in an optimistic scenario, approximately 180 mines and over $150 billion would be required. Benchmark also predicts that recycled lithium will contribute nearly half of the supply by 2050.

Divergence among investment banks is also significant. Just as Citi downgraded its forecast, Mizuho raised its end-of-2027 lithium carbonate price forecast from $18,375 per ton to $22,500 per ton. These figures are not directly comparable: Citi provided a three-month target price, whereas Mizuho provided a forecast for a point more than a year away. This precisely illustrates that the market has little dispute regarding short-term oversupply; the controversy centers on how long the oversupply will last and when the reversal will occur.

Benchmark CalculationValue
Demand increment 2026–2050Approx. 4.8 million tons LCE
Required new mines (base case)134 mines, approx. 36,000 tons/year each
Required investment (excluding recycling)Over $100 billion
Optimistic scenarioApprox. 180 mines, over $150 billion
Required investment before 2040 (including recycling)Approx. $64 billion
Share of battery-grade lithium in 202692%

A long-term deficit and short-term oversupply are not contradictory; the contradiction lies in timing. From exploration to commissioning, new mines typically take seven to ten years, while price signals transmit on a monthly basis. Today’s low prices are delaying tomorrow’s investment decisions: when spodumene drops to around $1,300 per ton, most new projects that have not yet made final investment decisions struggle to secure financing. The experience following the lithium price crash in 2023–2024 was that a batch of high-cost overseas projects were delayed or shut down, ultimately driving a price rebound in late 2025 to early 2026. If history repeats itself this time, the reversal is likely to occur after the second half of 2027, rather than in the first half of next year.

06 Assessment

The first half of the oversupply cycle

Minlibang’s judgment is that lithium prices have entered the first half of the oversupply cycle. The first half of 2027 will primarily involve grinding at the bottom, with the main lithium carbonate contract likely operating in the range of RMB 80,000–100,000 per ton. A true reversal requires the clearance of high-cost capacity and the postponement of new projects, which will take at least two to three quarters.

First, the significance of Citi’s price cut lies in its “qualitative” implication rather than its “pricing” function. The $12,000 figure is roughly in line with the current spot price excluding taxes, indicating that investment banks no longer anticipate a rebound during the peak season but instead accept the combination of “improving supply and slowing demand.” Once such views become mainstream, the willingness of industry chain participants to replenish inventories will further decline, suppressing both the strength and sustainability of any price rebound.

Second, the cost floor is the most critical reference point from below. With spodumene falling to around $1,300 per tonne and expectations rising for the resumption of lepidolite mine production, the high end of the cost curve is being tested. If lithium carbonate remains below RMB 80,000 per tonne for an extended period, cash flows for some high-cost lepidolite mines and African mining operations will turn negative. Production cuts will shift from “rumors” to “actions,” which serves as a signal for market bottoming.

Third, demand divergence warrants close attention. While retail sales of new energy vehicles (NEVs) in China are declining, exports and energy storage systems (ESS) continue to grow. If ESS orders demonstrate resilience in the first quarter of next year, the bottom for lithium prices may appear earlier than markets fear. Conversely, if exports are also hampered by trade barriers, the period of oversupply could last longer than expected.

07 Outlook

Three signals to watch for a turning point in lithium prices

Tracking Point 1: Resumption pace at Jianxiawo and domestic monthly output. Jianxiawo has an annual capacity of approximately 100,000 tonnes of lithium carbonate equivalent (LCE) at full production; its resumption speed determines the upper limit of incremental domestic supply. If China’s monthly lithium carbonate output reaches 120,000 tonnes in December and continues to rise, the time required for price bottoming will be delayed. A slowdown in output growth would indicate that cost constraints are beginning to take effect.

Tracking Point 2: Whether spodumene can hold above $1,200 per tonne. Citi’s new target price is $1,200/t, which also represents a cost-sensitive zone for many African and Australian mines. After this level is breached, attention should focus on whether mines announce production cuts, suspensions, or delays in expansion projects. These actions are more reliable turning-point signals than price movements alone. According to Mysteel statistics, shipments of lithium ore from Australian mines to China decreased by 47,000 tonnes month-on-month in October, indicating that mines are already reacting to lower prices.

Tracking Point 3: Energy storage orders and NEV exports. In the context of weakening domestic retail sales, energy storage and exports serve as the two pillars of demand. Monitor fourth-quarter ESS battery production schedules and monthly NEV export data. If both indicators slow down simultaneously, the scale of oversupply projected for 2027 may exceed expectations. For downstream enterprises, it is currently more appropriate to procure according to actual needs and lock in prices in batches; large-scale stockpiling during a downtrend is not advisable.

Low prices do not eliminate demand, but they do eliminate supply.

— END —