Metals Are Rising, Yet Iron Ore Is the Sole Decliner

All Metals Are Rising, Why Is Iron Ore the Sole Decliner?

What Appears to Be a Cyclical Correction Is Actually a Structural Bear Market Driven by Supply Surplus

Core Summary ● The World Bank’s October Outlook projects that its Metals and Minerals Price Index will rise by 25% in 2026, setting an annual average record (up from 17% in the April edition), with aluminum, copper, and tin hitting all-time highs; iron ore is a notable exception, with forecasts for 2026 and 2027 at $98 and $95/dmt respectively, below the 2020 average price of approximately $108/dmt (calculated). ● Singapore iron ore futures hit an intraday low of $89.25/ton on October 27, the lowest since September 2024; source material cites a price of $91.03/ton on November 3, representing a year-on-year decline of 12.91%, consistent with market trends, though specific figures have not yet been independently verified. ● Demand is contracting: China’s crude steel production from January to September totaled 725 million tons, a year-on-year decrease of 2.9%; supply is expanding: China’s iron ore imports from January to September reached 955 million tons, a year-on-year increase of 4.1%, with full-year volumes expected to set records, while the Simandou project begins ramping up production. ● Corporate data confirms: Vale reported Q3 earnings per share of $0.29 (compared to $0.63 in the same period last year), with net profit falling 53%; realized iron ore prices were $85.1/ton, down 10% year-on-year, and full-year output is expected to fall at the lower end of guidance. ● Mineral Cube Assessment: Iron ore is in a "structural bear market where low-cost mines remain profitable," with the price center shifting down to $85–$95/ton; as long as the cash costs of the Big Four miners are far below selling prices, supply will not voluntarily contract.

01 The Trigger

An Exception in the Metal Bull Market

On October 28, the World Bank released the October edition of its Commodity Markets Outlook. The report projects that the World Bank Metals and Minerals Price Index (including base metals and iron ore, excluding precious metals) will rise by 25% in 2026, setting an annual average record. It is expected to decline slightly by 3.3% in 2027 but remain 16% higher than the 2021 peak; aluminum, copper, and tin prices have already hit all-time highs. The World Bank also revised its 2027 price forecasts for tin and zinc upward by 22% and 13% respectively compared to the April edition. The "17% increase" cited in source material refers to the World Bank’s April edition figures, which have been updated to 25% in the October edition.

Iron ore stands out as an exception in this performance report. Maintaining its April assessment, the World Bank forecasts an average iron ore price of $98/dmt in 2026 and $95/dmt in 2027, citing pressure from weak Chinese construction activity, increased production from traditional exporting countries, and the commissioning of Guinea’s Simandou project. In a companion infographic released simultaneously, the World Bank noted that weak construction sectors in many economies and the softening of China’s steel industry will continue to weigh on iron ore. According to IMF quarterly data, the average iron ore price in 2020 was approximately $108/ton (calculated). The World Bank’s forecasts for 2026 and 2027 are both below 2020 levels, consistent with the source material’s claims.

Commodity2026 Forecast2027 Forecast
Metals & Minerals Index+25% (Record High)-3.3%
Copper$13,200/ton$13,000/ton
Tin—$45,000/ton (+22% vs. April)
Zinc—$3,100/ton (+13% vs. April)
Iron Ore$98/dmt$95/dmt (Flat vs. April)

Note: World Bank forecasts are based on information available prior to October 14 and represent annual averages; the 2020 average iron ore price is calculated by Mineral Cube using IMF quarterly data.

02 Background

Falling from $110 to $90

Iron ore prices have essentially trended downward throughout the year. On January 12, Singapore Exchange iron ore futures were trading at $109.2/ton, near a two-year high; by late June, prices broke below $100, hitting an intraday low of $97.8 on June 23. Entering October, the decline accelerated: touching $90.95 on October 5, briefly dropping to $89.85 on October 15, and reaching an intraday low of $89.25 on October 27, marking the lowest level since September 2024. This represents a cumulative decline of approximately 18% from the January 12 level of $109.2/ton (calculated). Dalian Commodity Exchange iron ore main contracts fell to between ¥660–670/ton during the same period, sitting at multi-year lows, described by various institutions as either two-year or four-year lows.

The acceleration in the October decline was driven by several simultaneous supply signals. According to industry data, as of the week ending October 11, iron ore inventory at seven major ports in Australia and Brazil increased by 1.99 million tons to 12.58 million tons; as of the week ending October 18, global iron ore shipments increased by 3.89 million tons quarter-on-quarter to 34.77 million tons. Ocean freight rates declined synchronously, with Capesize shipping rates from Australia to China and Brazil to China both trending downward, further depressing landed prices. Meanwhile, Chinese steel mills entered their blast furnace maintenance period, weakening immediate demand for iron ore. The simultaneous occurrence of "excess" on the supply side and "scarcity" on the demand side in October made prices breaking below $90 unsurprising.

TimeSingapore Iron Ore FuturesContext
Jan 12, 2026$109.2/tonNear two-year high
Jun 23, 2026$97.8/tonBroke below $100
Oct 5, 2026$90.95/tonLow since Sep 2024
Oct 15, 2026$89.85/tonWeakening demand, increasing supply
Oct 27, 2026$89.25/ton (Intraday)Lowest in over two years
Nov 3, 2026$91.03/ton (Source)Not yet independently verified

The $91.03/ton figure and 12.91% year-on-year decline provided by source material for November 3 align with this trend. For reference, the CIF price of Australian PB Fines on November 3, 2025, was $104.8/ton; calculating based on $91.03/ton yields a year-on-year decline of approximately 13.1% (calculated). In a year when aluminum, copper, and tin continuously broke records, iron ore has fallen back to September 2024 levels.

03 Breakdown

Demand Side: Steel Production Cuts

Iron ore demand depends on Chinese steel production. Data from the National Bureau of Statistics shows that from January to September 2026, China’s pig iron production was 628 million tons, a year-on-year decrease of 3.0%; crude steel production was 725 million tons, a year-on-year decrease of 2.9%; and steel product production was 1,067 million tons, a year-on-year decrease of 2.0%. Single-month crude steel production in September was 73.59 million tons, a slight year-on-year increase of 0.1% but a month-on-month decrease of 1.4%. Source material states "China’s crude steel production has declined continuously"; this holds true on a cumulative basis, but single-month year-on-year figures for September had turned to slight growth, so strictly speaking, it is "cumulative decline, single-month stabilization."

IndicatorVolumeYoY
Pig iron production (Jan–Sep)628 million tonnes-3.0%
Crude steel production (Jan–Sep)725 million tonnes-2.9%
Steel product output (Jan–Sep)1,067 million tonnes-2.0%
Crude steel production (September)73.59 million tonnes+0.1%
Iron ore imports (Jan–Sep)955 million tonnes+4.1%

Global demand is equally sluggish. In October, the World Steel Association revised its global crude steel demand forecast for 2026 from a 0.3% increase to a 0.1% decline, citing weakening demand in China and disruptions caused by tensions between the US and Iran. Analysts generally expect China’s crude steel production to fall for a third consecutive year, primarily due to ongoing adjustments in the real estate market. According to World Steel Association data, global crude steel production in September was 142.4 million tonnes, down 0.2% year-on-year; China’s crude steel production in July was 76.9 million tonnes, down 3.6% year-on-year. Growth in steel production outside China has been insufficient to offset the reduction in China.

Paradoxically, imports are increasing. From January to September, China’s iron ore imports rose by 4.1% year-on-year, adding approximately 38 million tonnes (estimated), with full-year volumes poised to set a record. One reason is the declining grade of domestic ores, forcing steelmakers to rely more on imported ore to make up for iron content; another is ample supply and lower prices, prompting steelmakers and traders to replenish inventories at low levels. With crude steel production falling while imports rise, the incremental volume ultimately accumulates as port inventory, which is the core force suppressing prices.

04 Breakdown

Supply Side: Major Miners Increasing Production

Vale’s Q3 results, released on October 29, serve as the most direct footnote to the iron ore bear market. Vale’s iron ore production in Q3 was 88.4 million tonnes, down 6% year-on-year, below the market expectation of 90.1 million tonnes, mainly due to lower run-of-mine ore supply at the Serra Norte mine; however, sales reached 86.3 million tonnes, up 0.3% year-on-year. The realized price for iron ore fines was $85.1/tonne, down 10% year-on-year; total fines costs rose by 23%, driven primarily by increases in diesel, marine fuel, and freight rates.

Vale Q3ValueYoY
Iron Ore Production88.4 million tonnes-6%
Iron Ore Sales86.3 million tonnes+0.3%
Realized Price of Fines$85.1/tonne-10%
Net Profit Attributable to Shareholders$1.255 billion-53%
Earnings Per Share (EPS)$0.29$0.63 in the same period last year
Adjusted EBITDA$3.508 billion-20%
Base Metals EBITDA$1.105 billion+61%

Management maintained its 2026 iron ore production guidance of 335–345 million tonnes but expects it to land at the lower end, relying on increased production at Serra Norte and the resumption of operations at the Fábrica mine in September to drive recovery in Q4. Iron ore C1 cash cost guidance remains at $22.5–$23.5/tonne, with all-in cost guidance at $58–$62/tonne. Based on the realized price of $85.1/tonne, Vale still retains an estimated all-in profit margin of approximately $23–$27 per tonne of iron ore (estimated). Copper and nickel businesses are expected to reach the upper half of their guidance ranges, with base metals EBITDA increasing 61% year-on-year, partially offsetting the decline in iron ore. In Q3, Vale’s copper production was 85,500 tonnes, down 6% year-on-year, and nickel production was 49,700 tonnes, up 6% year-on-year; pellet production is expected to fall at the midpoint of the 30–34 million tonne guidance range.

There are several notable details in Vale’s Q3 report. First, revenue did not decline significantly; net revenue grew 2% year-on-year to $10.6 billion, exceeding market expectations, with the drop in profits primarily driven by rising costs. Second, the Fábrica mine, which had been suspended due to environmental damage caused by a spill earlier in the year, only resumed operations in September. Third, capital expenditure for 2026 is expected to be at the lower end of the $5.4–$5.7 billion range. Falling prices, rising costs, and production below expectations created triple pressure, causing Vale’s profits to halve.

Rio Tinto is also increasing production. Rio Tinto’s iron ore sales in Q3 were 90.8 million tonnes, up 3% year-on-year; production from January to September was 259.6 million tonnes, up 4% year-on-year. At Simandou, calculated on a 100% basis, production from January to September was 3.7 million tonnes and sales were 1.7 million tonnes, still in the early ramp-up phase. In January this year, the first commercial shipment of Simandou ore arrived at Chinese ports, marking the official entry of the world’s largest undeveloped high-grade iron ore project into the supply side. Mysteel previously estimated that shipments would accelerate after the rainy season, with total annual shipments potentially exceeding 20 million tonnes, a figure that differs significantly from Rio Tinto’s disclosed figures; subsequent official data should be used as the benchmark. In October, the China Mineral Resources Group, established in 2022 to coordinate iron ore import negotiations, reached a new supply agreement with Rio Tinto, alleviating market concerns about supply availability and also viewed as one of the factors driving prices to four-year lows.

05 Comparison

Institutional Forecasts Are Uniformly Bearish

Unlike the lithium and nickel markets, there is virtually no divergence in institutional forecasts for iron ore. The World Bank forecasts $98/tonne in 2026 and $95/tonne in 2027; BMI (Fitch Solutions) lowered its 2026 average price forecast from $99 to $95/tonne; the consensus among institutions compiled by GMK Center is $94/tonne for 2026. Regarding the mention of Vale’s US stock hitting a 12-month low, the data we found indicates that Vale’s ADR closed at approximately $11.40 on October 30, down about 36% from its 52-week high of $17.94 (estimated); the specific claim of a “12-month low” could not yet be verified through independent sources.

Institution2026 Forecast2027 Forecast
World Bank (October)$98/dmt$95/dmt
BMI (Fitch)$95/tonne (previously $99)—
GMK Center Consensus$94/tonne—
Goldman Sachs (October 2025)$93/tonne, Q4 at $88—
Current Singapore Futures~$89–$91/tonne—

The implication of this table is that current prices have already fallen below the full-year forecasts of major institutions: based on $90/tonne, this is approximately 8% lower than the World Bank’s 2026 forecast and about 5% lower than BMI’s forecast (estimated). In other words, the market is trading not for 2026, but for the supply-demand dynamics after Simandou ramps up in 2027. The World Bank’s 2027 forecast is $95/tonne, but if Simandou ramps up as planned and China’s crude steel production continues to decline, this forecast still has room to be revised downward. Goldman Sachs judged in October 2025 that China’s steel industry has returned to oversupply, predicting iron ore prices would fall to $88/tonne in Q4 2026; this judgment is gradually being realized.

06 Assessment

Low-Cost Mines Are Still Profitable

Mineral Cube’s assessment is that iron ore is in a structural bear market where “low-cost mines remain profitable,” with the price center of gravity having shifted down to $85–95/tonne. As long as the cash costs of the Big Four miners are far below selling prices, supply will not contract voluntarily, limiting the scope for price rebounds.

First, this is structural rather than cyclical. The hallmark of a cyclical correction is a brief demand downturn followed by rapid price recovery after inventory destocking; however, iron ore faces three consecutive years of declining Chinese crude steel output and depressed mill profitability, while large new capacity such as Simandou has only just begun ramping up production. The demand ceiling is moving lower, and the supply floor is rising; these two trends are unlikely to reverse within one or two quarters.

Second, cost support lies below but remains distant from current prices. Vale’s C1 cash cost is approximately $23, with full costs around $60. Even if prices fall to $85, mainstream mines still retain profits. Vale previously stated its intention to reduce iron ore C1 costs to $18–19.5/tonne and increase production to 360 million tonnes by 2030, indicating that the expansion appetite of low-cost mines has not diminished. Mines facing genuine cost pressure are China’s domestic high-cost mines and some small-to-medium exporters; their exit would constitute the price bottom, a process typically involving prices breaking below cost lines and persisting for several quarters.

Third, energy costs are the sole variable. Conflicts in the Middle East this year drove up diesel, marine fuel, and ocean freight rates, increasing Vale’s fines total cost by 23%. If energy prices recede, mine costs will decline, further lowering the price floor; if conflicts escalate again, higher freight costs will temporarily lift landed prices but will not alter the oversupply dynamic.

07 Outlook

Three signals to identify the iron ore bottom

Tracking Point 1: The ramp-up speed of Simandou. Under Rio Tinto’s metrics, Simandou sales from January to September totaled only 1.7 million tonnes, remaining in its initial phase. Monitor Q4 shipments following the end of the rainy season in West Africa (July–September), as well as shipment guidance for 2027. The faster shipments approach full capacity, the lower the price center of gravity will be in 2027.

Tracking Point 2: Chinese crude steel output and port inventories. Single-month year-on-year crude steel output turned slightly positive in September; whether this trend continues in Q4 depends on steel exports and infrastructure demand. Simultaneously, monitor iron ore port inventories; if inventories continue to rise despite record imports, prices will remain under pressure.

Tracking Point 3: Production guidance and costs of the Big Four miners. Vale’s 2026 production is expected to land at the lower end of its guidance range; watch for any downward revision to its 2027 guidance, as well as the shipment rhythms of Rio Tinto, BHP, and FMG. For steelmakers, it is currently advisable to maintain low inventories and procure according to need; for traders, spot premiums and term structures reflect true supply and demand dynamics more accurately than absolute prices. Looking longer-term, BMI previously projected that iron ore prices would enter a multi-year downtrend, with the average price falling to approximately $78/tonne by 2034.

Copper and aluminum are chasing rallies, while iron ore is undergoing clearance.