Sixth consecutive year of deficit, yet silver prices have halved.

An apparent supply-demand imbalance masks a rapidly narrowing shortfall.

Key Takeaways ● On November 12, the Silver Institute released preliminary estimates in New York: the global silver market will face a deficit of 35 million ounces in 2026, marking the sixth consecutive year of deficit. The cumulative deficit from 2021 to 2026 is approximately 746 million ounces. ● However, the deficit is narrowing rapidly: forecasts in February predicted a deficit of 67 million ounces; the April World Silver Survey revised this down to 46.3 million ounces; and by November, it was further reduced to 35 million ounces. HSBC’s October estimate was even lower, at just 5 million ounces. ● Silver prices fell from a historical high of approximately $121.65 per ounce in January to around $52 on November 4, representing a decline of approximately 57% (calculated); year-to-date, prices are down 27%. ● The primary driver of the narrowing deficit is photovoltaics (PV): higher silver prices accelerated silver reduction and substitution, with PV silver consumption expected to fall by 21% this year. Meanwhile, recycling volumes increased to 210 million ounces, the highest since 2012, while ETPs are projected to see net outflows of 45 million ounces for the full year. ● MineCube Analysis: A book deficit does not equate to physical tightness; silver released from ETP sell-offs has already exceeded the annual gap. The narrative of a deficit cannot sustain silver prices; direction is still determined by interest rates and investment capital.

01 The Catalyst

New Figures for the Sixth Year of Deficit

On the evening of November 12, the Silver Institute held its annual industry dinner in New York, releasing preliminary 2026 supply and demand forecasts completed by Metals Focus. The conclusion is that the global silver market will experience a deficit of 35 million ounces this year, remaining in a state of supply shortage for the sixth consecutive year. The cumulative deficit from 2021 to 2026 is estimated at approximately 746 million ounces.

The key word behind these figures is "narrowing." In February, the Silver Institute forecast a 2026 deficit of 67 million ounces. The April release of the World Silver Survey 2026 lowered this to 46.3 million ounces, and this latest update brings it down to 35 million ounces—a reduction of approximately 48% over eight months (calculated). The Institute itself stated that the narrowing deficit, combined with metal released from ETP sell-offs, has alleviated tension in the physical market. The April World Silver Survey had previously estimated a cumulative deficit of 762.1 million ounces for 2021–2026; the cumulative figure has now been revised down by approximately 16 million ounces (calculated).

Price movements have been more volatile than fundamentals. Data from the Silver Institute shows that silver prices hit a record high of $121.65 per ounce on January 26, before retreating to approximately $52 on November 4, marking a 27% decline for the year. Most market data indicates that the intraday high occurred on January 29, ranging between $121.62 and $121.67. While different metrics vary by a few days, the magnitude remains consistent. Calculating from $121.65 to $52, silver prices have fallen by approximately 57% (calculated).

Looking back at 2025, the Silver Institute’s final data showed mine silver production grew by 3% to 846.6 million ounces, recycling increased by 2% to 197.6 million ounces, and total demand fell by 2% to 1.13 billion ounces. Industrial demand declined by 3% to 657.4 million ounces, resulting in an annual deficit of 40.3 million ounces. This indicates that industrial demand began declining as early as 2025, with this year seeing an acceleration driven by higher silver prices. Nevertheless, industrial demand this year remains approximately 22% higher than in 2019, indicating that silver’s industrial base has not disappeared.

Item2026 ForecastYoY Change
Mine Silver834 million ozapprox. -1%
Recycling210 million oz+6%
Total Supply1.045 billion oz-3%
Industrial Demand640 million oz-3%
Of which Non-PV Industrial492 million oz+4.5%
Jewelry148 million oz-22%
Silverware35 million oz-17%
Bars & Coins215 million oz-2%
Total Demand1.081 billion oz-5%
Supply/Demand Gap-35 million ozSixth consecutive year

Note: Preliminary estimates by the Silver Institute and Metals Focus on November 12, excluding ETPs.

02 Background

From $121 to $52

This round of silver market activity began in 2025. At the start of 2025, silver prices were around $30 per ounce. On October 9, they broke through the $49.95 record held since January 1980, a benchmark maintained for 45 years, pushing prices to near $83 by year-end. Entering 2026, silver prices rose approximately 70% in January alone, reaching $116.67 intraday on January 26, before surging above $121. Calculated from the start of 2025 at approximately $30, silver prices had accumulated a gain of approximately 279% at their peak.

The turning point arrived just as suddenly. On January 30, U.S. President Trump nominated Warsh to succeed Powell as Federal Reserve Chair. Markets began pricing in sustained high interest rates. According to Standard Chartered Bank data, silver prices fell 26% on that day, dropping more than 30% within roughly 30 hours, breaking below $75. The physical market experienced extreme tension both before and after the peak. On January 26, the online precious metals dealer APMEX implemented trading thresholds, requiring a minimum buy of $500 and a minimum sell-back of $20,000. By mid-February, silver prices stabilized temporarily around $80; by mid-September, they were around $66; and on October 30, they fell to $50.95, the lowest level since November 2025.

TimeSilver Price (USD/oz)Event
Early 2025approx. $30Start of rally
Oct 9, 2025Broke $49.95Broke 1980 record
Jan 26–29, 2026approx. $121.65Historical high
Jan 30, 2026Below $75Single-day crash after Fed Chair nomination
Mid-Feb 2026approx. $80Temporary stabilization
Oct 30, 2026$50.95Lowest since Nov 2025
Nov 9, 2026approx. $52.40Low-level consolidation

The gold-silver ratio also reflects this drastic shift in valuation. In January, the ratio briefly dropped to 43, the lowest since 2011, indicating that silver was being aggressively favored relative to gold. By early November, the ratio had returned to a high level of over 70. Silver fell harder and faster than gold, a dynamic linked to its smaller market size and stronger investment attributes. The factors driving the surge at the beginning of the year were not limited to supply and demand: silver was added to the U.S. Critical Minerals List in November 2025, and rumors circulated that China would restrict silver exports. The Silver Institute later clarified that these reports were inaccurate.

03 Breakdown

Why is the deficit narrowing?

The biggest variable is photovoltaics (PV). The Silver Institute expects PV silver demand to fall by 21% this year, due to lower-than-expected installations, particularly in China, and high silver prices accelerating silver reduction and substitution. JPMorgan’s estimates are more aggressive, forecasting a 30% decline in PV silver demand this year, amounting to approximately 60 million ounces. Philip Newman, Managing Director of Metals Focus, judges that the peak for PV silver demand has passed and will continue to weaken.

Analysis from US precious metals dealer APMEX also points out that annual silver requirements for PV are decreasing; the engine driving the deficit over the past five years has begun to reverse. According to their estimates, a shortfall of 30 to 40 million ounces represents only about 3.5% of global supply.

PV carries significant weight. Over the past five years, PV accounted for 55% of the increase in silver demand, but may reverse approximately half of that increment by 2030. As the largest engine driving the deficit begins to run in reverse, a narrowing of the deficit becomes inevitable. Fortunately, non-PV industrial demand is still expected to grow by 4.5% this year, partially offsetting the decline in PV.

On the supply side, output is increasing. High silver prices make recycling profitable; recycled supply is expected to grow by 6% to 210 million ounces this year, the highest level since 2012, with increased jewelry recycling in China, India, and Turkey. On the demand side, jewelry demand falls by 22% and silverware by 17%, as Indian consumers shift to smaller, lighter styles and gold-plated jewelry. US retail investment is expected to drop to its lowest level since 2010, while Indian bar and coin demand is projected to decline by 10%. Forecasts for investment demand have also been significantly downgraded: previous predictions suggested physical investment would grow by 20% to 227 million ounces, setting a three-year high, whereas the latest calculation indicates a 2% decline to 215 million ounces.

FactorChangeImpact on Deficit
PV Silver Demand-21% (JPMorgan estimate -30%)Narrows deficit
Non-PV Industrial+4.5%Widens deficit
Recycling+6%, highest since 2012Narrows deficit
Jewelry-22%Narrows deficit
Silverware-17%Narrows deficit
Bars and Coins-2%Essentially flat

04 Deconstruction

ETPs Release Inventories

Whether a deficit implies physical tightness depends on inventories. Data from the Silver Institute shows that as of November 3, global silver ETF holdings stood at 1.25 billion ounces, having decreased by 55 million ounces year-to-date, a drop of 4%; they have rebounded by 24 million ounces since the end of June, partially offsetting outflows in the first half of the year. Metals Focus forecasts a full-year net outflow from ETPs of 45 million ounces.

Putting these two figures together, the implication is clear: the 45 million ounces expected to be released from ETPs over the full year exceeds the 35 million ounce supply-demand deficit, meaning the market is digesting the deficit and leaving approximately 10 million ounces of additional circulating silver (estimated). This aligns with what the Silver Institute describes as "physical market tightness easing."

Comparison with last year highlights the change further. In 2025, investors poured approximately 278 million ounces into silver ETPs, combined with a supply-demand deficit of approximately 40 million ounces, causing the effective deficit to briefly exceed 318 million ounces; whereas this year, ETPs have shifted from buyers to sellers. Despite both scenarios being labeled a "deficit," last year saw investment funds scrambling for goods, while this year sees inventory filling the gap, implying completely opposite effects on price.

ItemQuantity
2026 Supply-Demand Deficit35 million ounces
Full-Year ETP Net Outflow Forecast45 million ounces
ETP Holdings (Nov 3)1.25 billion ounces
YTD ETP Change-55 million ounces
ETP Change Since End of June+24 million ounces
After Offsetting Deficit with ETP ReleaseApprox. +10 million ounces (estimated)

This also illustrates that silver prices are determined more by investment flows than by industrial supply and demand. Changes in ETP holdings often fluctuate with expectations for US interest rates and the direction of the US dollar; high bond yields have limited ETP inflows in the second half of this year; concerns regarding US government debt have brought periodic inflows, resulting in uneven capital movements. This logic is consistent with the gold article published by MiningCube on the same day: in an environment where the Federal Reserve resumes rate hikes, interest-free precious metals face overall pressure.

05 Comparison

Huge Divergence in Institutional Estimates

The large discrepancies among different institutions' estimates of the silver deficit are themselves a signal warranting caution. A late-October report from HSBC argued that the silver market faced a deficit of 140 million ounces in 2025, which would plummet to 5 million ounces in 2026, before expanding slightly to 12 million ounces in 2027; meanwhile, the Silver Institute's figure for the 2025 deficit was only 40.3 million ounces. HSBC's May estimates still projected a 2026 deficit of 73 million ounces. HSBC simultaneously provided average silver price forecasts of $75 and $68 for 2026 and 2027, with year-end target prices of $70 and $65, warning that the gold-silver ratio might widen, meaning silver could weaken even if gold rises. HSBC's supply and demand assumptions are: mine silver production remains basically flat at 848 million ounces in 2026, increasing to 868 million ounces in 2027; recycling increases to 216 million ounces; industrial demand drops to 642 million ounces in 2026 and further to 618 million ounces in 2027; jewelry demand falls from 189 million ounces in 2025 to 157 million ounces.

Institution & Time2025 Deficit2026 Deficit2027 Deficit
Silver Institute (Feb)—67 million ounces—
Silver Institute (Apr)40.3 million ounces46.3 million ounces—
Silver Institute (Nov)—35 million ounces—
HSBC (May)143 million ounces73 million ounces25 million ounces
HSBC (Oct)140 million ounces5 million ounces12 million ounces

Note: Different institutions use different supply and demand model methodologies; values should not be directly subtracted or compared.

Historical experience also reminds us that a paper deficit and price levels are not necessarily linked. Based on monthly average prices, after the January 1980 peak, silver prices fell cumulatively by 91% by March 1993; after the April 2011 peak, they fell by 67% by December 2015; in this cycle, from the January 2026 peak to July, prices have already fallen by 36%, and as of September, they remain 30% lower than in January. A deficit serves as medium-term support, not a price floor. The same study also found that within one year after silver sets record highs, prices were higher in 83% of cases, with a median increase of 63%; but extending the horizon to three years, prices were higher in only 45% of cases, below the average level of 59% across all months. Adjusted for inflation, the January 1980 monthly average price of $38.9 is equivalent to approximately $168 today, whereas the January 2026 monthly average price was $92.1, which has not yet surpassed the 1980 level in terms of real purchasing power.

06 Assessment

Deficits Cannot Sustain Silver Prices

MineCube’s assessment is that the paper deficit is losing its supportive effect on silver prices; interest rates and investment capital remain the determinants of silver’s direction. A gap of 35 million ounces accounts for only about 3.3% of global supply (estimated), and the inflows and outflows of Exchange-Traded Products (ETPs) over a single year are sufficient to cover it; under the trends of reduced silver usage in photovoltaics (PV) and increased recycling, the deficit in 2027 may continue to remain at low levels, or even approach balance.

Synthesizing the views of both institutions, the silver market in 2027 is likely to be in a tight balance range: HSBC forecasts a deficit of 12 million ounces in 2027, while the Silver Institute believes that sustained surpluses require extreme conditions. Newman also stated that after this year’s severe volatility, the return of investor interest could re-support the market. In other words, fundamentals have shifted from “persistent large deficits” to “approaching balance,” and silver price elasticity will derive more from capital flows rather than the supply-demand gap itself.

However, this does not mean there is no floor for silver prices. According to data from the Silver Institute, primary silver mine production this year is approximately 233 million ounces, accounting for only about 28% of mined silver (estimated); the majority comes as by-products from copper, lead, zinc, and gold mines. Higher silver prices do not quickly translate into increased mined supply; indeed, mined silver output is expected to decline by approximately 1% this year. Non-PV industrial demand continues to grow. The real risk lies in the fact that if interest rates continue to rise and investment capital continues to withdraw, silver price adjustments will be more severe than those of gold.

For the industry chain, a drop in silver prices from $120 back to around $50 reduces costs for PV module manufacturers, but the technological routes for reducing silver content and substitution have already been promoted and will not reverse due to falling silver prices. This implies that the decline in silver usage in PV is more likely to be structural rather than cyclical. The Silver Institute also noted in its April report that high prices make silver “the victim of its own success,” but transitioning to a sustained surplus requires a quite extreme combination of supply and demand changes; the more likely outcome is a gradual return to relative balance.

07 Outlook

Three Signals to Watch for Silver Prices

Tracking Point 1: Federal Reserve Interest Rate Decision in December. Silver is more sensitive to interest rates than gold; the magnitude of rate hikes and subsequent guidance will directly affect ETP capital flows; the meeting on December 8–9 is the most important event of the year. Technically, $50 marks the starting point of this rally last November, and some analysts view it as a key support level.

Tracking Point 2: Changes in Global Silver ETP Holdings. If ETPs shift from net outflows to sustained inflows, physical market tightness will re-emerge; conversely, if holdings continue to decline, the supportive effect of the paper deficit on prices will weaken further.

**Tracking Point 3: The World Silver Survey 2027 in April next year.** Key focus areas include whether the final 2026 deficit estimate will be revised downward further, and whether 2027 will see a transition to surplus for the first time; changes in PV installations and per-unit silver consumption are the most critical variables in this report.

A paper deficit of silver does not equate to a physical market shortage of silver.

— END —