Sulfur Nears $1,000: Copper Smelters Rebound on Sulfuric Acid, but Fertilizer and Hydrometallurgy Are the Real Losers

It may appear that smelters are reaping windfall profits, but they are merely recouping a portion of losses incurred from negative treatment charges.

Core Summary ● Hormuz Strait blockage traps roughly half of global seaborne sulfur; prices have surged from the usual $100–$200 per ton to near $1,000 per ton, nearly ten times pre-conflict levels. ● The "mining companies" winning bids are primarily hydrometallurgical copper mines requiring acid leaching and Indonesian HPAL nickel projects, rather than pyrometallurgical smelters. ● Pyrometallurgical smelters produce approximately 3.7 tons of sulfuric acid for every 1 ton of copper produced. Acid prices rose from 554 RMB/ton at the end of last year to 2,112.5 RMB/ton in July this year, significantly boosting by-product revenue; however, most remain loss-making due to negative treatment charges. ● Teck reduced operating rates at its two US facilities to approximately 50%. China’s phosphate fertilizer production fell by approximately 7% year-on-year in the first half of the year. Fertilizers are the biggest losers in this sulfur crisis. ● Mineral Cube Assessment: Sulfuric acid is shifting profits from fertilizers and hydrometallurgy toward pyrometallurgical smelters, leading to a revaluation of smelting capacity value. However, this is a phased dividend dependent on the situation in the Hormuz Strait.

01 Trigger

A Byproduct Disrupts Three Industries

According to a report from Cailian Press on October 13, severe shortages in global industrial sulfur supply have been caused by the outbreak of war in Iran and continued disruptions to transport through the Hormuz Strait. Prior to the conflict, approximately half of the world’s sulfur was transported via the Hormuz Strait. Sulfur prices typically ranged between $100 and $200 per ton; this year, they have approached $1,000 per ton, nearly ten times the pre-conflict level. An analysis by the Payne Institute at the Colorado School of Mines in July indicated that the strait’s blockage trapped approximately 50% of global seaborne sulfur trade, creating a global deficit of about 5.1 million tons. CIF prices for Middle Eastern seaborne sulfur to Asia once exceeded $800 per ton, with some Western benchmark peaks reaching approximately $1,500 per ton.

Sulfur is a byproduct of oil and gas processing, the vast majority of which is processed into sulfuric acid. This acid is primarily used in two sectors: phosphate fertilizer production and metal leaching in mining. In a market with limited supply, Argus analysts stated that mining companies are winning bidding wars, squeezing out fertilizer producers with thinner profit margins. Meanwhile, copper smelting operations are benefiting from high sulfuric acid prices, with industry insiders even reporting "acid-for-copper" swap agreements.

Sulfur Price IndicatorValueExplanation
Pre-conflict Norm$100–$200/tonCailian Press citation
Current LevelApproaching $1,000/tonNearly 10 times pre-conflict levels
Middle East Seaborne CIF AsiaOnce exceeded $800/tonPayne Institute, July
Some Western Benchmark PeaksApproximately $1,500/tonPayne Institute, July
Chinese Port Sulfur (Mar–Jun)Rose from 4,000 RMB/ton to 11,600 RMB/tonChina Nonferrous Metals Industry Association News
China Domestic Sulfur Average Price (Sep 24)Approximately 7,606 RMB/tonIndustry Weekly Review

It is necessary to clarify that while source materials describe both "mining companies" and "copper smelters" as beneficiaries, their positions in the sulfur chain are completely opposite: pyrometallurgical smelters are producers of sulfuric acid, while hydrometallurgical mines are consumers. Understanding this distinction is key to identifying the true winners and losers in this sulfur crisis.

02 Background

China’s Sulfuric Acid Market: Two Acids, Two Destinies

China is the world’s largest producer of sulfuric acid. According to statistics from the China Nonferrous Metals Industry Association News, in 2025, smelter gas-derived sulfuric acid accounted for 40.9% of China’s total sulfuric acid production, followed by sulfur-derived acid at 40.8%, and pyrite-derived acid at 16.8%. Smelter-derived acid became the largest source for the first time. This structure dictates that the impact of the sulfur crisis on China’s sulfuric acid industry is divergent.

Acid Production Route2025 Production ShareH1 2026 Operating Rate
Smelter Gas-Derived Acid40.9%Maintained above 70%
Sulfur-Derived Acid40.8%Dropped from approx. 70% to approx. 30%
Pyrite-Derived Acid16.8%—
Other1.5%—

The raw material costs for sulfur-derived acid enterprises skyrocketed with the surge in sulfur prices, causing operating rates to drop from approximately 70% to 30%, with most operating at a loss. In contrast, smelter-derived acid, being a byproduct of non-ferrous metal smelting, generally has costs below 200 RMB per ton, gaining a distinct cost advantage under high acid prices. In terms of pricing, sulfuric acid rose from approximately 554 RMB/ton to 980 RMB/ton over three months at the end of 2025. It surged again from March to June this year, with the benchmark price reaching approximately 2,112.5 RMB/ton on July 3, an increase of approximately 125% from the beginning of the year. By late September, prices retreated to approximately 1,737.5 RMB/ton, with some areas in Anhui, Hubei, and Jiangxi falling below 1,000 RMB/ton.

China’s sulfur supply is also under pressure. Approximately 45% of China’s sulfur relies on imports, with about 55% coming from the Persian Gulf. From January to August this year, China imported 2.9186 million tons of sulfur, a year-on-year decrease of 59.56%. Port sulfur inventories dropped from approximately 2 million tons at the beginning of the year to approximately 770,000 tons by the end of July, nearing a ten-year low. Starting in May, China suspended exports of ordinary sulfuric acid, with originally planned export volumes gradually returning to the domestic market.

China Sulfur & Sulfuric Acid IndicatorsValueTime
Sulfur Import DependencyApprox. 45%, of which approx. 55% comes from the Persian Gulf2026
Sulfur Imports (Jan–Aug)2.9186 million tons, down 59.56% YoY2026
Sulfur Imports (August)272,300 tons, down 65.03% YoYAugust 2026
Port Sulfur InventoryDropped from approx. 2 million tons to approx. 770,000 tonsBeginning of Year to End of July
Sulfuric Acid ExportsSuspension of ordinary sulfuric acid exports starting in May2026

03 Breakdown

Copper Smelters: Recovering, But Not Fully Restored

Pyrometallurgical copper smelting produces approximately 3.7 tons of sulfuric acid as a byproduct for every 1 ton of copper produced. Based on this ratio, as sulfuric acid prices rose from 554 RMB/ton at the end of last year to 2,112.5 RMB/ton in July this year, the sulfuric acid revenue per ton of copper increased from approximately 2,050 RMB to approximately 7,816 RMB, an increase of about 5,770 RMB (calculated). Even calculating based on the late September price of approximately 1,737.5 RMB/ton, the sulfuric acid revenue per ton of copper remains approximately 6,430 RMB (calculated).

Sulfuric Acid Price NodePrice (RMB/ton)Sulfuric Acid Revenue per Ton of Copper (Calculated, based on 3.7 tons)
End of 2025 Start PointApprox. 554Approx. 2,050 RMB
End of 2025 PeakApprox. 980Approx. 3,626 RMB
July 3, 2026Approx. 2,112.5Approx. 7,816 RMB
September 24, 2026Approx. 1,737.5Approx. 6,429 RMB

This is a substantial revenue stream, but does it allow smelters to “sit back and reap the profits”? The answer is no. As discussed in Minestats’ previous article on copper smelting for CSIS, long-term treatment charges (TCs) for copper concentrate were zero this year, while spot TCs for imported copper concentrate stood at approximately -$224.73 per tonne by late September. According to data from Shanghai Metals Market (SMM) on September 29, even factoring in profits from sulfuric acid, smelters still incurred losses of approximately RMB 4,300 to 6,100 per tonne. In other words, the significant increase in sulfuric acid revenue only partially offset the losses caused by negative treatment charges, failing to turn the overall industry profitable.

Nevertheless, the role of sulfuric acid cannot be underestimated. According to CRU statistics, in 2025, by-products contributed approximately 25% to 27% of smelter revenues, while refined metal contributions accounted for approximately 50% to 53%; treatment charges are no longer the primary driver of profit. Without the surge in sulfuric acid prices, smelter losses would have been deeper, and production cuts would have occurred earlier. Some smelters have even begun importing high-sulfur pyrite to keep their sulfuric acid plants operational and alleviate cash flow pressures. Additionally, according to China Nonferrous Metals News, several major smelters scheduled maintenance during the fourth quarter, which will further constrain the supply of smelter-grade sulfuric acid, providing some support for sulfuric acid prices.

04 Breakdown

The Real “Mining Buyers”: Hydrometallurgical Copper and Indonesian Nickel

The mining companies that won out in sulfur bidding are primarily hydrometallurgical projects requiring large volumes of sulfuric acid for leaching. Their common characteristics include high metal prices, thick profit margins, the ability to absorb higher sulfur costs, and a high degree of dependence on sulfuric acid supply.

The first category is hydrometallurgical copper mines in Chile and other regions. In 2025, Chile’s copper production was approximately 5.5 million tonnes, with about 1.1 million tonnes derived from solvent extraction-electrowinning (SX-EW) processes. Each tonne of copper consumes approximately 3 tonnes of sulfuric acid, corresponding to an estimated annual sulfuric acid demand of 3.3 million tonnes. Chile’s domestic smelting capacity is only about 830,000 tonnes/year, limiting the supply of smelter-grade acid. In 2025, Chile imported nearly 4 million tonnes of sulfuric acid, of which approximately 1.5 million tonnes came from China. China’s suspension of general sulfuric acid exports starting in May has further tightened raw material sources for Chilean hydrometallurgical copper mines.

The second category is Indonesia’s High-Pressure Acid Leach (HPAL) nickel projects. Producing one tonne of mixed hydroxide precipitate (MHP) containing nickel requires consuming approximately 25 to 30 tonnes of sulfuric acid. Sulfuric acid costs account for approximately 52% of MHP cash costs, compared to 29% for nickel ore. In 2025, Indonesia imported approximately 5.3 million tonnes of sulfur, with over 4 million tonnes coming from the Middle East. Morgan Stanley estimates that for every $1/tonne increase in sulfur prices, nickel production costs rise by approximately $8 to $10/tonne. As discussed in Minestats’ previous article on Limin’s listing, sulfur costs have become a core variable for Indonesian hydrometallurgical nickel enterprises.

Hydrometallurgical ConsumerSulfuric Acid / Sulfur DemandExternal Dependence
Chile Hydromet Copper (SX-EW)~1.1 million tonnes of copper, ~3 tonnes of sulfuric acid per tonneImported nearly 4 million tonnes of sulfuric acid in 2025, ~1.5 million tonnes from China
Indonesia HPAL Nickel25–30 tonnes of acid per tonne of Ni-containing MHPImported ~5.3 million tonnes of sulfur in 2025, >4 million tonnes from the Middle East
DRC Copper-Cobalt—Imported ~1.4 million tonnes of sulfur in 2025, ~90% from the Middle East
Zambia—Already imposed emergency restrictions on sulfuric acid exports last September

These projects succeeded in bidding because metal prices provided sufficient profit margins. With copper prices nearing historical highs of $15,000/tonne, Antofagasta’s profits in Chile grew by nearly one-third year-on-year in the first half. However, “winning” does not come without cost: rising sulfuric acid costs directly increased production costs for hydrometallurgical copper and nickel, though these were masked by high metal prices. According to Morgan Stanley’s calculations, as sulfur prices rose from a normal level of approximately $150/tonne to around $1,000/tonne—an increase of roughly $850/tonne—nickel costs increased by approximately $6,800 to $8,500/tonne (estimated).

05 Comparison

The Biggest Losers: Fertilizers

Compared to the metals sector, the fertilizer industry lacks the ability to pass on costs. Producing one tonne of diammonium phosphate (DAP) requires approximately 0.4 tonnes of sulfur, with sulfur costs accounting for up to half the value of the fertilizer product. Mosaic stated that due to limited farmer affordability, costs could not be fully passed on, forcing them to slow production; Morocco’s OCP also indicated an inability to pass on costs, shifting toward products with lower sulfur consumption and seeking alternative raw materials.

Fertilizer Company or MetricAction or DataSource
Mosaic US FacilitiesOperating rates at Florida Bartow and Louisiana facilities dropped to ~50%May report
Mosaic US Production Cuts~2 million tonnesMay report
Mosaic Brazil Production Cuts~1 million tonnesMay report
Mosaic Full-Year GuidanceWithdrew 2026 production guidanceMay report
OCP (Morocco)Shifted to lower-sulfur products, seeking alternative raw materialsOctober report
Chinese Phosphate FertilizersH1 production down ~7% YoY; MAP operating rate ~59%, DAP ~53%China Nonferrous Metals News

In China, phosphate fertilizers are also the largest user of sulfuric acid, accounting for approximately 50% to 60% of sulfuric acid consumption. In the first half of this year, China’s MAP operating rate was approximately 59%, and DAP was approximately 53%, with phosphate fertilizer production down by about 7% year-on-year. Losses among sulfuric acid producers made from sulfur and low operating rates among phosphate fertilizer companies constitute another side of the sulfur crisis in China. The Payne Institute, citing estimates from the UN World Food Programme, noted that over 45 million people face severe hunger, partly due to this round of supply disruptions.

Another notable source of new demand comes from lithium iron phosphate (LFP). China’s LFP production grew by 72% year-on-year in 2025. According to forecasts by China Nonferrous Metals News, LFP production will increase by approximately 1.4 million tonnes in 2026, corresponding to a new demand for approximately 3.458 million tonnes of pure sulfuric acid. The demand for sulfuric acid from the new energy industry has created new competition with fertilizers and hydrometallurgy.

06 Analysis

Sulfuric Acid is Reassessing the Value of Smelting Capacity

Minestats’ assessment is that this sulfur crisis is shifting profits from fertilizers and hydrometallurgy toward pyrometallurgical smelting, leading to a reassessment of smelting capacity value; however, this is a phased dividend dependent on the situation in the Strait of Hormuz, and smelters have not turned profitable as a result.

First, the relative competitiveness between pyrometallurgy and hydrometallurgy has changed. Over the past few years, hydrometallurgical copper and nickel expanded rapidly due to lower capital expenditures and shorter construction cycles. Now, with soaring sulfuric acid costs, the cost advantage of hydrometallurgical processes has been weakened, whereas pyrometallurgical smelting not only requires no external purchase of sulfuric acid but can also sell by-product acid. If this change persists, it may influence process selection for future copper and nickel projects.

Second, the phenomenon of smelters “exchanging acid for copper” warrants attention. Reports indicate that agreements have emerged where smelters supply sulfuric acid to hydrometallurgical copper mines in exchange for copper concentrate or other consideration. This means that under the regime of negative treatment charges, smelters have found a new bargaining chip. The tighter the sulfuric acid supply, the more confidence smelters have in negotiations with mines, which may have subtle implications for next year’s long-term copper concentrate treatment charge negotiations.

Third, the sustainability of the premium depends on the Strait of Hormuz. Kpler believes that the sulfur crisis is far from over and is worsening, with a large number of vessels still trapped in the strait. However, domestic sulfuric acid prices in China have retreated from their July highs; in the single week of late September, they fell by 5.57%. With ample supply of smelter-grade acid and weak willingness among downstream users to replenish inventories, it indicates that the domestic market has begun to digest the shock. Once shipping through the strait resumes, the speed at which sulfur prices fall could be as rapid as their rise, and the sulfuric acid premium for smelters will consequently narrow.

Fourth, for China, the suspension of sulfuric acid exports is a double-edged sword. It ensures the supply of sulfuric acid for the domestic phosphate fertilizer and new energy industries, but it also tightens the raw material sources for hydrometallurgical projects in Chile, Indonesia, and other regions, thereby increasing overseas copper and nickel production costs. From the perspective of global copper and nickel supply, this policy indirectly supports metal prices, which is a positive factor for Chinese smelting enterprises.

ParticipantBenefited or HarmedReason
Pyrometallurgical Copper SmeltersBenefited (partial recovery)Surge in revenue from by-product sulfuric acid, but still operating at a loss under negative treatment charges
Hydrometallurgical Copper Mines (e.g., Chile)Increased CostsNeed to purchase sulfuric acid externally; high copper prices temporarily mask this impact
Indonesian HPAL Nickel OperationsSignificant Cost IncreaseSulfuric acid accounts for approximately half of cash costs
Fertilizer CompaniesSignificantly HarmedUnable to pass on costs, forced to reduce production
Chinese Sulfur-Based Acid Production EnterprisesHarmedRaw material costs skyrocketed; operating rates dropped to approximately 30%
Lithium Iron Phosphate (LFP) Supply ChainIncreased DemandNew demand for sulfuric acid competes with the fertilizer sector

07 Outlook

Focus on three key items next

Tracking Point 1: Resumption of shipping through the Strait of Hormuz. Approximately half of global seaborne sulfur trade relies on this route. Whether normal shipping operations can resume is the only fundamental condition for sulfur prices to decline. The pace at which trapped vessels are released will directly determine the inflection points for sulfur and sulfuric acid prices.

Tracking Point 2: China’s sulfuric acid export policy and smelter maintenance schedules. China suspended exports of general-purpose sulfuric acid starting in May, originally planned to last until the end of the year. Whether this policy continues will affect raw material supplies for overseas hydrometallurgical projects in Chile, Indonesia, and elsewhere. In the fourth quarter, several major smelters are scheduled for maintenance, which will constrain smelter-grade acid supply and may provide support for domestic sulfuric acid prices.

Tracking Point 3: Long-term contract treatment charge negotiations for copper concentrate in 2027. Revenue from sulfuric acid is becoming a crucial pillar of smelter profits, and new transaction models such as "acid-for-copper" exchanges have emerged. Whether smelters can leverage sulfuric acid as a bargaining chip to secure better terms during year-end long-term contract negotiations will demonstrate the long-term impact of this sulfur crisis on the distribution of profits within the copper industry chain.

For the copper industry chain, the significance of sulfuric acid is being re-evaluated. It was once a by-product that smelters needed to manage, but it has now become a key revenue source determining whether smelters can survive the winter of negative treatment charges, and a critical raw material determining the costs of hydrometallurgical copper and nickel projects. The price of one ton of sulfuric acid is influencing the global landscape of copper and nickel supply.

By-products are no longer supporting characters; sulfuric acid has rewritten the smelting ledger.

— END —