The US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia ruled on September 11, 2026, that the Department of Energy overstepped its statutory authority by issuing an emergency mandate requiring a Michigan utility to operate an aging coal-fired facility beyond its scheduled decommissioning date. The appellate panel determined that Energy Secretary Chris Wright failed to demonstrate adequate legal justification for overriding conventional state jurisdiction over regional energy infrastructure.

This judgment represents the first major judicial reversal of the Trump administration’s campaign to stabilize the domestic coal market through federal intervention. The decision validates the legal challenges mounted by Michigan and Illinois state authorities, alongside an alliance of environmental groups, against earlier agency directives that targeted six additional thermal plants nationwide.

By striking down these emergency orders, the court eliminates a regulatory mechanism designed to delay the closure of existing coal generation assets. For coal markets, the ruling reinforces commercially driven retirement schedules and constrains federal attempts to artificially sustain demand for thermal coal through administrative mandates.